Valutazione sperimentale di tecnologie per la gestione dei dati per workflow scientifici
-
Upload
francesco-de-giorgi -
Category
Technology
-
view
432 -
download
0
Transcript of Valutazione sperimentale di tecnologie per la gestione dei dati per workflow scientifici
81,9(56,7$�'(*/,�678',�',�75,(67(
',3$57,0(172�',�0$7(0$7,&$&RUVR�GL�ODXUHD�PDJLVWUDOH�LQ�,QIRUPDWLFD
/DXUHDQGR)UDQFHVFR�'H�*LRUJL
5HODWRUH3URI��(ULF�0HGYHW
&RUUHODWRUH'RWW��3DROR�9HUFHVL
9DOXWD]LRQH�VSHULPHQWDOH�GL�WHFQRORJLH�SHU�OD�JHVWLRQH�GHL�GDWL�
SHU�ZRUNIORZ�VFLHQWLILFL
$QQR�DFFDGHPLFR����������
7HVL�VYROWD�SUHVVR�(VWHFR�6�S�D�
,QGLFH
6&(1$5,2
62/8=,21(
5,68/7$7,
&21&/86,21,
9(5,),&$
352%/(0$7,&$
6FHQDULR
Ɣ ZRUNIORZ�GL�VLPXOD]LRQHż PRGHOOR�PDWHPDWLFR�GL�XQ�VLVWHPD�GD�VLPXODUH
II
I
II
YDULDELOL�GHFLVLRQDOLLQ�LQJUHVVR YDULDELOL�GL�ULVSRVWD
6FHQDULR
GDWL�GL�SURJHWWR�
Ɣ 3URJHWWRż ZRUNIORZ�GL�VLPXOD]LRQHż YDULDEOL�GHFLVLRQDOL�LQ�LQJUHVVRż YDULDELOL�GL�ULVSRVWD
II
I
II
YDULDELOL�GHFLVLRQDOLLQ�LQJUHVVR YDULDELOL�GL�ULVSRVWD
6FHQDULR
Ɣ 'DWL�GL�SURJHWWR�LQ�ZRUNIORZ�GL�VLPXOD]LRQHż XWLOL]]DWL�LQ�SUREOHPL�PXOWLRELHWWLYR
Ŷ SUREOHPL�FRQ�SL��GL�XQD�IXQ]LRQH�RELHWWLYR
IXQ]LRQHGD�PLQLPL]]DUH�R�GD�
PDVVLPL]]DUH
3UREOHPD
0HPRUL]]D]LRQH�GL�GDWL�GL�SURJHWWR
Ɣ 6LWXD]LRQH�DWWXDOH��JHVWLRQH�YLD�5'%06ż ��PHWRGL�QRQ�VWDQGDUG
3UREOHPD
0HPRUL]]D]LRQH�GL�GDWL�GL�SURJHWWR
Ɣ 6LWXD]LRQH�DWWXDOH��JHVWLRQH�YLD�5'%06ż ��PHWRGL�QRQ�VWDQGDUG
,327(6,
QRQ�q�OD�PLJOLRUH�QHO�FRQWHVWR�GL�ULIHULPHQWR
$QDOLVL�GHOOD�SUREOHPDWLFD
Ɣ &DUDWWHULVWLFKH�GHL�GDWL�GL�SURJHWWRż WLSR�HWHURJHQHR
Ŷ SULPLWLYLŶ FRPSRVWLŶ ILOH��-621��-3(*��&$'���RJJHWWL�ELQDUL
35,0,7,9,
��
IDOVH
��������������
�JDUJDPHOOD�
&203267, ),/(
D�EL
&203267,
D�EL
),/(),/(),/(),/(),/(&203267,
D�EL
&203267,
D�EL
&203267,
D�EL35,0,7
,9,��
IDOVH
��������������
35,0,7,9,
��
IDOVH
��������������
35,0,7,9,
��
IDOVH
��������������
�JDUJDPHOOD�
$QDOLVL�GHOOD�SUREOHPDWLFD
Ɣ &DUDWWHULVWLFKH�GHL�GDWL�GL�SURJHWWRż �JUDQGL�TXDQWLWj�
Ŷ VFKHPD�QRQ�GHWHUPLQDELOH�D�SULRUL
35,0,7,9,
��
IDOVH
��������������
�JDUJDPHOOD�
),/(&203267,
D�EL
$QDOLVL�GHOOD�SUREOHPDWLFD
Ɣ &DUDWWHULVWLFKH�GHL�GDWL�GL�SURJHWWRż VFDUVDPHQWH�VWUXWWXUDWL
),/( 5$:�'$7$
B��%!A+A'!�%'!>��)!A?۪C�)'!!�&�!�)&!A*���!�')!�'%!C
"
/LPLWD]LRQL�GL�XQ�5'%06
Ɣ Ê�DGDWWR�D�JHVWLUH�L�GDWL�GL�SURJHWWR"
IDOVH
��
��������������
�JDUJDPHOOD�
D�EL
/LPLWD]LRQL�GL�XQ�5'%06
Ɣ Ê�DGDWWR�D�JHVWLUH�L�GDWL�GL�SURJHWWR"ż (WHURJHQHLWj
IDOVH
��
��������������
�JDUJDPHOOD�
D�EL
/LPLWD]LRQL�GL�XQ�5'%06
Ɣ Ê�DGDWWR�D�JHVWLUH�L�GDWL�GL�SURJHWWR"ż (WHURJHQHLWjż 4XDQWLWj
IDOVH
��
��������������
�JDUJDPHOOD�
D�EL
IDOVH
��
��������������
�JDUJDPHOOD�
IDOVH
��
��������������
�JDUJDPHOOD�
IDOVH
��
��������������
�JDUJDPHOOD�
D�ELD�EL
D�ELD�EL
D�ELD�EL
D�ELD�EL
D�EL
/LPLWD]LRQL�GL�XQ�5'%06
Ɣ Ê�DGDWWR�D�JHVWLUH�L�GDWL�GL�SURJHWWR"ż (WHURJHQHLWjż 4XDQWLWjż 0DQFDQ]D�GL�VWUXWWXUD
5$:�'$7$
B��%!A+A'!�%'!>��)!A?۪C�)'!!�&�!�)&!A*���!�')!�'%!C
"
2ELHWWLYR
$FTXLVLWL�L�OLPLWL�GL�JHVWLRQH�FRQ�5'%06
,QGDJDUH�EDVL�GL�GDWL�DOWHUQDWLYHƔ 1RQ�QHFHVVDULDPHQWH�UHOD]LRQDOLƔ 'HYRQR�ULVSHWWDUH�L�YLQFROL�GL�VFHQDULR
9HULILFDUH�OH�DOWHUQDWLYHƔ &UHDUH�XQR�VWUXPHQWR�GL�YHULILFD
%DVL�GL�GDWL�DOWHUQDWLYH
Ɣ 7HFQRORJLH�1R64/ż 1RW�2QO\�6WUXFWXUHG�4XHU\�/DQJXDJH
Ɣ 0RGHOOR�GL�GDWL�QRQ�UHOD]LRQDOHż FROXPQ�RULHQWHG��NH\�YDOXH��GRFXPHQW�RULHQWHG�����
Ɣ 5LVSHWWR�GHL�YLQFROL�GL�VFHQDULRż WLSL�GL�GDWL�HWHURJHQHLż JUDQGL�YROXPL�GL�GDWLż GDWL�VHPL�VWUXWWXUDWL�R�QRQ�VWUXWWXUDWL
99
9
%DVL�GL�GDWL�DOWHUQDWLYH
Ɣ $OWUL�YLQFROL�ż PDQLSROD]LRQH�PHGLDQWH�-$9$�$3,ż PDQWHQHUH�SURSULHWj�$&,'
Ɣ %DVL�GL�GDWL�1R64/�FKH�ULVSHWWDQR�L�YLQFROL�
%DVL�GL�GDWL�DOWHUQDWLYH��&DVVDQGUD
Ɣ 0RGHOOR�FKLDYH�YDORUHż L�YDORUL�VRQR�FRORQQH
%DVL�GL�GDWL�DOWHUQDWLYH��0RQJR'%
Ɣ 0RGHOOR�GRFXPHQW�RULHQWHG
%DVL�GL�GDWL�DOWHUQDWLYH��2ULHQW'%
Ɣ 0XOWLPRGHOż JUDSK���GRFXPHQW�RULHQWHG
Ŷ YHUUj�XWLOL]]DWR�FRPH�GRFXPHQW�RULHQWHG
2ELHWWLYR�GL�VSHULPHQWD]LRQH
Ɣ *HVWLUH�L�GDWL�GL�SURJHWWR�FRQ�'%�1R64/�ż JUD]LH�DOOR�VYLOXSSR�GL�XQR�VWUXPHQWR�GL�YHULILFD
II
I
II
YDULDELOL�GHFLVLRQDOLLQ�LQJUHVVR YDULDELOL�GL�ULVSRVWD
,GHD�GL�VSHULPHQWD]LRQH
Ɣ 3HQVDUH�L�GDWL�GL�SURJHWWR�FRPH�RJJHWWL�-DYD
YDULDELOL�GHFLVLRQDOLLQ�LQJUHVVR
YDULDELOL�GL�ULVSRVWD
-$9$�2%-(&7
6SHULPHQWD]LRQH
Ɣ 3HQVDUH�L�GDWL�GL�SURJHWWR�FRPH�RJJHWWL�-DYDż DUELWUDULDPHQWH�FRPSOHVVL
&20326,7(%($1
6,03/(%($1
0$3%($1
,QWHJHU�LQW�6WULQJ�VWU�
6LPSOH%HDQ�VE��6LPSOH%HDQ�VE��6LPSOH%HDQ�VE��
0DS�6WULQJ�������6LPSOH%HDQ!����������������VE0DS�
6SHULPHQWD]LRQH
Ɣ 2SHUDUH�VXL�1R64/�FDQGLGDWLż PROWH�RSHUD]LRQL�&58'��FRQ�H�VHQ]D�YLQFROR
6% 6%
&% &%
0% 0%
6% 6%
&% &%
0% 0%
1R64/�'%
6% 0%&%
&%6%
0%
&UHDWH5HDG
8SGDWH'HOHWH
�ZKHUH����
6SHULPHQWD]LRQH
Ɣ 2SHUDUH�VXL�1R64/�FDQGLGDWLż PROWH�RSHUD]LRQL�&58'��FRQ�H�VHQ]D�YLQFRORż YHULILFDUH
L� WHPSR�GL�HVHFX]LRQH�GHOORSHUD]LRQH
6% 6%
&% &%
0% 0%
6% 6%
&% &%
0% 0%
1R64/�'%
6% 0%&%
&%6%
0%
6SHULPHQWD]LRQH
Ɣ 2SHUDUH�VXL�1R64/�FDQGLGDWLż PROWH�RSHUD]LRQL�&58'��FRQ�H�VHQ]D�YLQFRORż YHULILFDUH
L� WHPSR�GL�HVHFX]LRQH�GHOORSHUD]LRQHLL� IDFLOLWj�GL�PDSSDWXUD�GHOORJJHWWR
6% 6%
&% &%
0% 0%
6% 6%
&% &%
0% 0%
1R64/�'%
6% 0%&%
&%6%
0%
0DS�"
0DS�.�9!
,PSOHPHQWD]LRQH&/,(17 ����� 6(59(5
/DSWRS�0DF%RRN�3UR,QWHO�&RUH�L�����*+]
0DF�2V�;-'.��1HW%HDQV����
/DSWRS�0DF%RRN�3UR,QWHO�&RUH���'XR����*+]
8%8178�90LQ�0$&�2V�;�KRVW
5LVXOWDWL�VSHULPHQWDOL
Ɣ /HWWXUD�GHL�JUDILFL
180(52�',�(/(0(17,
7(032',�(6(&8=,21(
>VHFRQGL@
1R64/�'%��RSHUD]LRQH��W\SH2I%HDQ
PHGLD�VX�WUH�ULSHWL]LRQL
,QVHULPHQWR�GL�6LPSOH%HDQVHFRQGL
QXPHUR�GL�HOHPHQWL
,QVHULPHQWR�GL�&RPSRVLWH%HDQVHFRQGL
QXPHUR�GL�HOHPHQWL
,QVHULPHQWR�GL�0DS%HDQVHFRQGL
QXPHUR�GL�HOHPHQWL
/HWWXUD�GL�6LPSOH%HDQVHFRQGL
QXPHUR�GL�HOHPHQWL
/HWWXUD�GL�&RPSRVLWH%HDQVHFRQGL
QXPHUR�GL�HOHPHQWL
/HWWXUD�GL�0DS%HDQVHFRQGL
QXPHUR�GL�HOHPHQWL
/HWWXUD�YLQFRODWD�GL�6LPSOH%HDQVHFRQGL
QXPHUR�GL�HOHPHQWL
&RPPHQWR�DL�ULVXOWDWL
Ɣ 0RQJR'%�q�LO�'%��PLJOLRUH�ż VXO�WHPSR�GL�HVHFX]LRQH�GHOOH�RSHUD]LRQL�&58'
Ɣ 2ULHQW'%�q�LO�'%��SHJJLRUH�ż VXO�WHPSRż PD�DOOD�SDUL�FRQ�0RQJR'%�SHU�OREMHFW�PDSSLQJ
Ɣ &DVVDQGUD�VWD�QHO�PH]]Rż KD�EXRQL�WHPSL�GL�HVHFX]LRQHż PD�OD�OREMHFW�PDSSLQJ�QRQ�q�LPPHGLDWR
&RQFOXVLRQL
Ɣ 0RQJR'%�q�LO�PLJOLRU�VHUYHU�1R64/ż 1HOOR�VFHQDULR�GL�ULIHULPHQWR
Ɣ 6YLOXSSL�IXWXULż 7HVW�HVDXVWLYL�VX�DOWUL�WLSL�GL�GDWRż &RPSDUD]LRQH�GLUHWWD�1R64/�5'%06ż 6YLOXSSDUH�PRGXOR�1R64/�SHU�(VWHFR