Aeres s1 Ensa Nantes 2011

7/23/2019 Aeres s1 Ensa Nantes 2011

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/aeres-s1-ensa-nantes-2011 1/36

Section des établissements

septembre 2011

Rapport d'évaluation de l’Écolenationale supérieure d’architecture

de Nantes



((/%( 2011

R$ '>$.$ ( .;&.($$.( >(( $&+(&(

( N$(

L( P>( ( .AERES

Didier Houssin

S(& ( >$%.(/(

Le Directeur

Philippe Tchamitchian



2



((/%( 2011 3

I0&0 5

L$ $>*( (0 /$?( ( (&+(&+( 7

I L( (0(. ( (&+(&+( 7

II L$ $>*( ( (&+(&+( 7

III L$ /( (0 ( ( .( ( .$ $>*( ( (&+(&+( 8

L$ $>*( (0 /$?( ( $.$0 9

L$ $>*( (0 /$?( ( )/$0 11

I L( .$*( ( .))( ( )/$0 11

II L$ .%.> ( %.> ( .))( ( )/$0 12

1 L$ &//0&$0 .))( ( )/$0 12

2 L$ &$$&> $&&(. $ (&( ( .$ .( ( (&(/(0 ( (0$0 12

3 L$ .&.0$>, .0 ( )0(/(0 ( >( (0 $&+(&( 12

4 L$ )(00$.$0, 0&( $0 .( &$( &//0 ( >( $&+(&(,

$/>( $ .E0$ N$0( 13

5 L$ )/$0 &00( )$$0 .%( 0( .( *0$.( 13

III L( ) 0)/$0 ( $&&/$*0(/(0 ( .>$0 13

I" L(000(/(0 ( $$. ( >$0 14

" L$ >/$&+( $.> >$**( 14

L$ $>*( (0 /$?( ( ( >$0( 15

I L/.&$0 ( >$0 $0 .$ ( ( .>$%.(/(0 15

II L( ) ( $( (/($0 $ >$0 ( %>0>)&( 0( >(..( $.> ( ( 15

1 "( ( ( &.(..( 15

2 A&&(. ( $&&/$*0(/(0 16

3 Q$.> ( .$ ( ( &$( %= 16

L$ $>*( (0 /$?( ( $(0$$ 17

I L( >(.(/(0 ( (.$0 0(->$%.(/(0 (0(*0(/(0 >( 17

II L( (.$0 $(& .( &..(&> ($.( 17

III L( (.$0 $(& .( /.( &>&0/( 17

L$ $>*( (0 /$?( ( (.$0 0(0$0$.( 19

S//$(



4

L$ *(0$0&( 21

I L( ?/( *$0$0 ( ( .$*( 21

II L( .$*(, .( >(.(/(0 ( .$ $.> ( ?/( 0)/$0 ( ( &//0&$0 22

III L$ .( (0 /$?( (/., ( /$( $.$$.( ( ( *(0 ( (&( +/$0( 22

I" L*$0$0 ( .( .$*( ( .$ .( %*>$( ( )0$0&?( 23

" L$ .( //%.?( : *(0, /$0(0$0&( ( >(.(/(0 $/0( 23

"I L( >(.(/(0 ( .$ &$$&> $>$.$0 $ (&( 0( /(..(( ())&$&>( .$&0 24

"II L( /$0$*(/(0 ( .$ $.> 24

L$))/$0 ( .(0> ( .>$%.(/(0 < $( 0( .(( &//0&$0 25

C0&.0 ( (&//$0$0 27

I L( 0 ) 27

II L( 0 )$%.( 28

III L( (&//$0$0 28

L( ( *.( 29

O%($0 (&( 31

O*$0$0 ( .>$.$0 35



5

[ > =?<?< [<>>?< ">= (E= ">=) => ? >==> ? <><=><> (E$A) =?= >?> ? =>< C?>?< > C?> (!CC), => <> ?<=? = @> = [<>>?< =><.

D?= @<< 2009, => > =?< [] ">=, = ? >> 18 000 2 & (12 000 2 =?< ?>) =><?> < = <>>= > > ==, ? V?< [? <> ?< ?< ?< ><>=. C>> >> = X?<>< <>Y, cluster <> < ??> ?< ">=,=> <=> < [ ? = = =>> =><>? = X= @<> <?,=>>?> > <><Y.

$<>, [E= ">= ? ? =><> @=> <<> = < [=>

<> > > >?, =[?> =?< >> == <><= << > =?< ? =>><=? = [=> =?<?< ? O>= [?@<=> > = <= = >< ">= &>-"<> < $= <. E => < == ? $<= [@<=> ">=, A<=, != ([ 1) ><> C< = <= = = $= <2. D > > >> <>?< ? ?<=?= <>>/?< @ [ >< ">= (EC"), = ? =><= ->= [? @[?@<=> ">= > [?>< @ [EC" > [ = =, = ==> ? = ><=(ED 498 & - &= ?< [?<, ==, <>>?< ; ED 501 D=> - D<>, -=>, =>,><<><=), = <>= @ [ ? = > @ $>[">=. U <>< <> > [<>>,[> [E= => @< = ?= O= X[?> <>?Y ==< [< <==> @<=< = ><= > = =>>?>= [<. C>> <=>@ => ?== < =><?> ?>=<><>= @ = >@>= ><<><=, = >==>= ?= <> ><? (E$CI), ? ? ( =><?>, O < @ > -=><?>) > ? ?>?< @

=?= [ ? ? >? <=? <>. C>> ?@<>?< =[> ??<[? @ @> [?><>=> = <>=.

A@ [=>> = ? ?@? =>, [E= ">= @? = >> ?>< =>< ?< ><2003 > 2009 ( 1,1 !\ 2,1 !\). [? => > =><>@ > <> <?@. C= 45,5 E'$' >>?<= > === ??= =[?>> 53 E'$' [=>= ><>?=, [? =>< 800 850 >?>= > 130 ?@? ><>= > @< ? > O= [<>> < . <= B>= <<=> 39,25 E'$. ><= = =>= => @=> << ? = = ><=<><= ? > [E= ">=. [=> => = >@> == ? << <? ?@? >.

I0&0

1 $<= [, < 2009, <== ??<[? 11 <= >?<= (?@<=> ">=, ?@<=> [A<=, ?@<=>

? !, >< ">=, = = ">=, A<?= #?=>, #<=, CH ">=, CH [A<=, G<?

E&A, A? ">=) > 18 <= ===, > [E= ">=.2 C< = <= = = $= < <<? = 19 <= = <, >= ">=, A<=,

@ > !=.



6



7

I L( (0(. ( (&+(&+(

<< ? = [E= ">= <= =?< ><= <><=.

C>< << >? [<>>?< (C<) < 1971, =>, @ C>< <<=?< [= =< > [@<> ?< [E= G< (C<==), [? = ? <><= =>>?>= 1998 [! 1563 ? C"& A= <>>?<= > ?<= =?= >?> > ? !CC > ? C"&, > A< [A<= 2010. C>> ! >> <= 31 =>=, EC ? <?<= <<= ? === > 3 <?<=C"&. C< ><? >> ! ?< 8 =>= ? EC (> 4 E=), 4 ?<= << (!CC > C"&),5 >=, 13 ><>=. <>< => == = => > =?> = ==?= [ > = <><=> > > = = = <> <>>?<?<, [>< = == ?< [?< > = &H&. [EC" => ? ?= ? = >> ?>. <<> [@?> [A<= <@ ? = <<= ? C< <<=>> ? ><?> > = ? =>? ? <. E 2009, = <==?<= >> <> 389 000 \ <==?<=>= > 60 000 \ <==?<= <<=.

<>< =, >= ?<=, ><>= (?) < 1989, > 1990 < !CC, => ><=?< X<? [?<Y > =?< = X<= [?<>Y. I =[> [? <>< ?<=< &H&. ? > @? 2011 < [A<= (A). I => = 13 =>= ? EC, <<= ? ===, 2 ?<=,>= > >= =><>= > 5 ><>=. <= => > << = <<=. [E=><? ?< 11 =>= <<= ? ===, 2 B>=, 3 ><>=. <<> [@?> [A<= > ?[>@> =>? = <<= => ?>, @ ? < < <? [?< <=@ @> = <= [?<>. E 2009, = <==?<= >> =[@> 8 000 \ <==?<= >= > 24 500 \ <==?<= <<=. C <>< > ? <@? ?, Lieu! communs, ?=>>? [? = <<= ><?= =>?= [ > =?< = <<>= >< [<>>?< > [?<.

G<? [>? > << =? <>>?< (G<=) > < 1990 C<>-F<<> ><=< [E= ">= 1999. I > > 2005 < !CC. [? => = ><= =>= [E= > @<= ><?>?<= ><?<= <>> ? == >=. E =?> ><= ><>=, <= =[?><= <><= [= >>?< [? HD. E 2009, [?> ==> 104 000 \ <==?<= >=> 6 000 \ <==?<= <<=. [A<= <@, 2011, ? <> [?> => @> >?> ? ><>=>?, <? < ? < ?= <== ? =>?, > < ? <>>> ?=><?>?< =>?> <?, ?< ? ?> >< >> > ?< >< @ (> C).

[E= ">= => >==> == [ED & ? >>< ? C<. E =< > == ?< < ??> [ED D=> < ?. C>> ==> ? ED [ > ? >< ? => ">= > ?< ? <?@> = <<= = = = @>?<= (<<?>> <?<=,=?>= >== > HD) @ ? @=> ><> ? > =< >?> [>>>. D?= =<>, [E= ">= <>, @ [EC" > <>< >< = >= > ?=== (C$C), [I=>>?> << == > >?= @ (I&'), ? < < [? <> << (F 2488). E

@> =[==< <== [? <> F (A<>, ?>?< > ><<><=) @ = ?@<=>= ">= > [A<= = ?[@ [ > = ?-<>= ">= >< (E"&BA"!).

II B L$ $>*( ( (&+(&+(

[E= ">= <> = [> =?< ? =><> << @> >< > <?@<[=>. E [ > >< = >> = @< 2007 [? = =>? (C&) <= ?= >>= <=> = E= <@> ?[? == > << (C$). E [ >=?<>?> > = <>= <><?, => <? (EC", ?@<=>, ED), => >? (E= G<). <> ? =?==> > =?< >?< = <<= <> ?< >= [<>>?<, [?< > = := ><= ==?= << ?, << >, << <>?-?, << <>, =[?> >. [< ><==< ? =?=> = <<= >< = >?<= > ?<= <><= = = <>= <>?<= [@>=. C& ?> @< ? ? <@ [<> = <>>= =><>?= [E= <>< = <>= ?>= < = <><=. C>> @?>=> = @ = = <> < = $><= (DG$, -<> [<>>?< > ?>< <>>?<, D) >< [ =>>?> << < = E=. C> <> @<>?> <>?<> @=< <<< = ><> = <><= > [E= ">=.

L$ $>*( (0 /$?( ( (&+(&+(



III B L$ /( ( ( ( .( ( .$ $>*( ( (&+(&+(

= <=== [E= [> = @-<=>, <>?<->, =<@ <<.D= [<< > @<< 2010, = <><= > ?< =><> ?> < ? =?><= =<@= =><>= (=><> < >?=, ? > ?>, >?). >

=><> << > = = V?@< => >< = = = = <><=.

E @< 2006, CA <>@< C&. & == ==> << = <>= = = !(=>< <<, <?<= << <> > = <>>=) > D (<>= ><=). I =>< ?=< > @<=< << = = << >, = = <>= [=>, <=< <<>> = = = ==> [>==> ?< <<< = >> <<. <=? C& > < ==? ? <>?< <>< ( ?). E < 2009, CA => ?@? C& : 6 <= <>, 6 <= = <><=, 2 <=>= ><?<=. <?@> ? C& ? ? <= 2011, <=> <=>> < ? = ?>. I => >< ? <>?<[? ?>< <><, C<, > [? = ? =>= <?= < == <= ? CA [E= 2010, <>>= ? = <= <> << = = =>= <> > [<>> [E=.

A? = ? C&, <<=>> = <><= => ?< > ?< > : 3 <<=>>=

>< 2 ?< ? > 1 ?< G<=. <>> ? C< [ED & > >O> ? ? [ED D=> <<< >> = <><=. C =>> > ?< <>@> > ?< > =><?< = <>=@>= @ = <><= ><?<=. E ?><, ?< <<> =? = >> X<Y ?@ <L> =?> <>> ; = ? =<@= (>< ?>>), > >< <> ?<= =><>=. C =?@>, = <><= > = <?<= => = <>?<= = =><>= <<. D= , ? bottom-up => =. <> [ < <>= <><= =?<= <>= > == = <@> ? <><=, @< ? <?<=, [< ? <==?<= <= >? =>= ==.

C& =>>? =<= ? => ?>?=> = <>= >< << == >?>=>< @<>> @? [=> [<> [? =><> << [E=.

8



9

E @< 2008, [E= < ? <> = <><>= > = <>= ??= = <=>@ @<=< = <><>= ?= > <@= ?= ?>?< <>= <@> == === (=>,<<, ?= ?>?<) > < [=>> = = ?@? >> ? V?< >< >=.

[< <> [E= => @<= > ?>, >> >< [=> > ?[ >< <> <== >?. E => << < ? <= >@ = = ? = ?=> < ? <><> @ = =><?>?<= =?= > >?= < $= <.

[E= >< ? < @> @<=< == >@>= <<, < = ?>= <<= ?<><= [, <>?< > = <= ? ? Lieu! communs, [> @<=, ? <=<> = ? < < <@?= >= > ><>= > <>> <? ?= >

<=. E =>< 2010, [E= = <= = <<= <><= ><= =?< << <>>?<,?< > =< F< > E?<.

">= ? ><= ?@<>?< [ =?< => < ? >? == <>=, == <>=??= > = >> ><, ? >> = >>= @ = =>>?>= = > <= = ?[<=> =>>= (=<=, <=, =>=) =>= ? ? == > ? <?.

C= >= =>= @> >< ?= < [=, ?< >, [? >> @=? ?? XE=">=Y ? <>><> @<, ?- >? ><>? > ?=, ? @<> >? @<=>.

L$ $>*( (0 /$?( ( $.$0



10



11

I B L( .$*( ( .))( ( )/$

F<> 45,5 E'$' [=>= >>?<= > ===, [ ? 800 850 >?>= > @< ? 95 O= [>?= <>>?< (?=> ? O [>> [<>>) <> < > 98 <> < =><, = ? [?><= O= <> >? > = [?><= <>=.[< <> [E= => @<= > = @ ><= <>= > ? O [>> [<>> :<>= > (3+2), <== >? (AE, 3+1) > ? ?<=?= <>>/?< ->>@ [EC" (7 =). C= <>= ?> =?< [>> L><= [V?@< = << (H!"#$). U= <>= =[?>> ? =><= ->= (!2 ', = > ><<><= ; !2 &>?, &= > >?= [@<> ?<) > ? O= <<= ? E= (D$EA <>>?< @, < 1990, ? <=

!2, > =<, ><= = <= ). E, [E= <> <<< ><> [<>>?< ><== ? = == <><= <<.

[E= <L> ? >==> ? > ><= =< = >< >= > ? [=> =?<?< <. [ <> >@> [< ? => ?@<=>< (< = <=,><>= =<=, ?>?=>). A<= @< = @ [EC" ? ? ?<=?= <>>/?< 2008, ><@ ?= <= [?><= <<>= >< <>>= > ?<= ( =?<?< ? = ?$>[">=) ? @ [?><= == (> > @ [ < A?). E =>?==, >, < == ? $<= [ > = ? ED. G< ? <><> << @ [E= G<, =><?> ? => ><. C>> ? <<? ?<<>> = ><?@< <= < ? ? =. A=, [?><= <>= =>< [>-= ? >< = V?@<, =>< -= = ?== > = =<@= -> >< [?@<=> ">= > [E&BA"!, ? X?<>< <>Y.

C >< <<, = [=><> (CA) [ = = @-<=> < [=>. E ><> @ C&, ? = = >?= (CE) > = 2003. CE X @> < >?>= = ?=>= <>@= ? >?= > @? <<< = == ? CA >/? @< = V?@< = <<= [=>Y ; => = @> =>= =< CA > <= < [? [>< ?. $?< == ><@?, =[? =?< ? =<@ = >?=, < ? <>?<> =>< 2007 > > <O > ==> = =><?>?<> [< <>.

=><> [=> <= ?== =?< ? ><= ==> <<. = ?[? ><= ==>= >>?<= [E= = =< <<. D= ?< <>?, = =>= @<> ===> >= <<= <<, <= << . E ? , = ?>< = [>? =>, >?> ? <>, === ? <>< << : > ><> (?), ?>?<= =><?>@= >=><>= <> (C<), <>= > >= ? <> <>>?< > ?< (C<), <>= <>>?<=

(G<=). '?= = >?>= => >= << @ < << ? ?<= ? !1. E, ? <?<=<>?< => <= ? >?>= ? @=> > << ?< ?< <> [>?=, @ ==> => = ? <><. C>> <>> => >, [ @?, < ==> [? =<> = ?ED, ? <> <<< ><> <>>?<, = [>==> [=<> = =><>@>= ><>=.

= =>= > ?? ><@ <<< ?@ >> ? << <> (2011-2015). <>> = =>= @@>= > >< =?, ?>?< >= <>>= =?< ==> [>< ?<<> [>= < ==><, =?< <> = E, =?< <O O> ? = ==>< (&6) > =?< ? <=> ad hoc (< <>==< = = ?= ><>= ? = ? ><= > <>?= > <>>?< > ?< - '$CA).

CA == = <> = = ?< @<< [?> == ==. E [= <>

><?<, > ? ? ? [>@>= <> = ?[? ?> == = >=<?= = <?= = <>= =>= (CA, CE, C&, AE) <> [= = >?<= [>==>,< ?< ?= @ [><>.

L$ $>*( (0 /$?( ( )/$0



12

II B L$ .%.> ( %.> ( .))( ( )/$

1 L$ &//&$ .))( ( )/$

& [?> ?< = ><= [<>>?< => < F<, >> ">= (350 =

[=<> 2000, 650 2006, 1 800 2010), => =?<<, <= <>? = <-=<>=?>= [ >, [>><>@> < [ ">=. "=, <>= =>= <?,>= ? < > = <>>= [ 1, = ? [?@<>?< ? ? ?<=?= <>>/?<@ [EC", ><?> = >><>@>.

$?< = >? [<>, [E= ? = ?@<>?< =?< < >= < [><< <><>= =>>?>=, = ==> [== =?< [] ">= > @> >[<>==. <> [? => <>?< = <>= ??= > = <><>= <>= >>@>. = = ><>= ?> = E=, >= ? => > = ?<= <>=?@<>=, => > ==. C>> ?> = ?<=?> ? ?<= = >?= < @<> [>?>,? > <> [< <>.

2 L$ &$$&> $&&(. $ (&( ( .$ .( ( (&(/( ( ($

C>> > => @> <=><> < < [=>= ? < = ? > = ==.> >< [<>, [E= =[=> >> @<=< = < < = <><>= @ [?><==>>?>=. < ?<= = ?<=?> = >> @ ?< @<=< = ><><= <?===. D > @?, [=> ? !2 ' => =>@ : [=> = !1 ', = ? = <>< [? !1 <, ?@<>? << [<>>?< [E=. D= >> <=>@, => =?> <=>< =><=<=== = <>= [ =>== < == ? !D : =<, <>>?< @. D$EA <>>?< @, <>< B'& > = <, < = =><?< ? =>< > @ >? !1.

<<?>> =>-?<> => < ? = E= : <=> =?< ==<, ?= ><>=@ = =>= (400 450 >= ? ? => < [=<>=). 130 >= @< => = >20 =<>= =?< => ><. C>> <?<, ? [@> = =, = =, =>=> = <>=

=>= ? <<<> @<< = >= [? ?= < < [@= ? ?<= 1< . '?>= =E= ==> > <?<<>, [= [@?> <>>> =?<< [?> >< <?==> ??<= = >?= > ==> [><. =><> [ <?==> ?<<> =[?< =?< = <=?>>= ==>. [E= ">= @<> = >< = ?< @<< [> = ==> <<?>> < ?=?@ @. U = <, = = =><>= >?= = E= ? <>>> ?< << >><?>. =?=>>?> == @> = >?=, = <= <=== ? ?=<== (AEE$$) ? ?<= ==>< =?< ? [ = <? ><O< = >= [= ? =>< = >?>= >>?<= [? , ? = < ? == ?>>? !. $<-== === = (<<> ? 20 ?> 2005), >> == ?><>, [E= ">=, ?< < [== <=?>>= > >>< = <=>= <<>>, ? <@, ?<=, ?<= = =?= =>[= = =>= ? ==><.

D= = <O ><> <> AE, == AEE$$ ><> ?=?[ 180 ==<= < . A<= ?<=>, = >= => <?= ><>. = >= <>?= ><> >?= << ==>< 1< , ?= = => <>= = = ==><= [=> <>= = ?<= ?=. C>> ==>(>=> ? ?<= ? << ==>< 1) = <= < <= [? =?=> = ==>=[><> = [?><= ==><=, ? <=? << = >= >< = >=. C>> ==, < <, < = >?>= > = <=>= ><?<=. = <>>= [> > === = >= <?= =. E, ? ? = <==>< =?< <= ==, ==?<?=?[ < <>.

3 L$ .&.$>, . ( )(/( ( >( ( $&+(&(

?<=<> => <=> [ ? >, >> [>< >< = == ?<[?< (&$I) > = == ?= > == (&H&). # <@ ? <> [<=> ?<=<>

><@<= = E ><=@<== P = <>= == = <=> (@< < = = >< =>< >?>?<= <>>?<= W HCA W > == > >?= ?< [<>>?< W &'A, ? >< <>= > >?=



<<=>> W A' W > '$CA). = = = <> = =?=> >< @ ? <=? @>< <?= [=>= >>?<= > @><= > >? ? > ? = E= L><=> = <<?>> ==>= < = ?<= >? > <?<> ?== = @><=. C ? = => <> ? <<==>< [E= P '$CA [=> ? ? < ? =? >>?< =?< ?> =>=. A contrario, >? <<?>>= [=>= @><= < ? ? <=== <.

4 L$ )($.$, &( $ .( &$( &// ( >( $&+(&(,$/>( $ .E$ N$(

A?- ? => ?@<< 1< , [E= ">= =? >>< = >= <= => 3 . => => @= ? = ><= ==. << < ==> ? = =>?><== = ? ? <?>. = <, ?= <, < < [? =?@ @? >< <= [? ?< < = > ?>< =. C? >?> > ><?@< ? ? =?< ?><, < = [? L>< =>. =>, <= < = =>=, => >< ? E >>?X <>?, < @@Y, = ? = >?>= => >= <=< ? ?>@?> ?<= ><=<<= = [>?=. E =><, => => > =?@ < = =>= ==, >? ? =>>> == [<> @? = =>=. E, H!#"$ > [> [? < <> >? <> ? = >?>= <>> <= < L><= [V?@< (@< 35 % = <>>=

O= [>> < ).

5 L$ )/$ &( )$$ .%-( ( .( *$.(

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

III B L( ) )/$ ( $&&/$*(/( ( .>$

> => [E= ?><= ? ? <> = >?>= < [? =><>@ > [?

=>, =?= < [? <? <>< = [>><. = =>= <>?<= ?==>< => <=>= > >> =, = ? <= =><> < => [.= ? = <= ?= [E= ">= => <>= ?< @>< > >< = >?>= <><.[> = >?>= => >? < = =>= > < [? =><>@. > =><><<> > ?? < => = ? = ? =<@ = >?=. $?< = >?>= ><<=, ? > [? =>< ?<= <=.

<> >? =><== = >?>= 1, <@ < = =<@= =>, <> ? >>> <>?<.[> >=>< ?> [= = >?>= ? << ==>< > >< > <?< @>< = >== ==@=. = >? [ <@=, [@< 10 %, > = >? [, [@< 6 %, ==>?> >?> >> ?= = = E=. "=, = ?>= <><= = = [@?> = =>= < = >?>= <>>> = =?<< <>> [?> >< =>= ?=, = ==>= [=> > = >= = >?>=. I => <> [?>< <>

= [@?> = =>= < = >?>= (= = <> [<=> = >?=)? ?<<> >< < < [?><= <><= (< ? @?> < = <=).

13



I" B L((/( ( $$. ( >$

= ?@? ? <> = =?<= > = ?>= @= =[= => < =?=><<= < <= > = >?>=. ><> ><@ [ 1, <=> = = = ?, ? = [? >< = = ?><=> ><@ =?< ><= >= ><? (=, >,

<>). [@<> <>? > <<?> => ? <= >?= = E= > > ><@ =>?>=. &?< = 140 =>>= ><@ <>?, 50 => = <. [= ? => => ?@<> < .

[E= ">= =? @< ? >? ?>< <. >? Z => >@ ?= ? <=? A<<= = E=. E => => = = @<> > < ? < <> =?<[= = ? [<>>?< = <. = ?@? ? > <= ? = <> ? @<= ?<[= = @=, ? = =>? = < = E=. @ => <>? => . E<> =?>> > <=<@> . <> [? >? ? ? <><= <<,== >?= = >?>=, => =?< ( <>?< [= ? >==). $?< ? ?< <> > ?< >< [=, = ? >?= => =>?= =?< @?, <> [? [?><. ">= ? >?, = ? V?< [E=, => ><= == ? ?<= <= [?@<>?< [>==>. =?@<= ?@> >< <=<@= via *, <>< [? > >?<. = <>= ><>?= => <= ? =? <=? A<<=.

" B L$ >/$&+( $.> >$**(

[= [=<@>< = ?= => ? ? <>> [E= ">=. ? = =>= @> < <>. =? => =[>< > ? > [? =<@>< = ?= => D$EA <>>?< @. C> ?> =>>? ? <>> ?< >>=>< [><> <>,??<[? ?> <?. ? < = <<= =, ? > [= [,[ = ><? < ==< [?< [? > ?>, == ?< =?<< @<=> <=== ><= [<>>?<.

14



L$ $>*( (0 /$?( ( ( >$0(

I B L/.&$ ( >$ $ .$ ( ( .>$%.(/(

'?= = ? =, = @= => = <<=>>= ? CA. = @ >?> (CE), =>>?><, > = ? <>= 2010 ?< >< = <>= @ = @= > ?< <<< ? ? <>>. I => =>>? <<=>>= = >?>= : ? < ?< <> >, ? <<=>>= <>= >?= > === > ? ?< = ><>=. & = >?>= => = ? CE, = =>=?@> @>= <=? ?- ><> = <<=. I= <>> >, < >?, [?><====. C = ?? [E=, >? <>> ? >= => ><= (8 % <<) ; ?<<> >< < < ? ?< <=>> ? @= ? <O = =>= <<=>>@=. A@ = ?=? CA > ? CE, = >?>= => ><= ? >= [E=. CE => @? ? < >?< [,<> ? @= ? < =/>= <, < > <=>= [<< ?< >=

[>?= : <> ? ? ><-<>, ?> ><. = <= ? CA, <> , => =?@> = >= ==>=. [ = > =?>< > [?<< = <?@> ?.

C[=> =<@ = >?= ? =[? @ >?> = = @= @> <= =>< ?=?<=><<= ; ? <== ?? ?<<> >< ?> ?<= = @= > >< ?.

= >?>= > < ? [==>=, <>= <>?<> >@= >= ? E=?==, =<> ?< ><<=, C, @> ?<>?<=, [E=-'=, ? <?> >><, =>=<>@ ?< <>? = >@>= =?=, C<<>>, C-?, BDE- (?= ? ==>= << ? @ ==>@ ) ? <= X</=<=Y [><?<, >>= ?<=, =>= > =>@ ? A<?>?<, =>> ?>?< < [E=. C =>@ > < <= [=>>= = ?@? ? < [==> . I = <? @= @= > <?<> ? ?<<>. = >?>= => <>> ?= > > > ?< >= <> [. [E= ? ?

=?@> 7 500 \ =>@ = ? = =?@>= =?< = ==>=. D= <>= <==?@> > >< =?>?= <= >? = ==<= < CA, [ ? 4 '< 2009.

!< >?>, @ ==>@ = L>< >?> ? <?, >> == = ?@> ><? < ? ? >< <=, ? = >< <, = ?== < ?@= <>= ><=><=== < ?<= >?=. =? = >> ? ? >?>= => B<[@, = @ = >=> = = ?>O> >=. @ ==>@ = ><?@ = = < < ? << > <<>>> <==> > [ >< >?>=. D ?=, ?<? = @= (BDE) <> @ =?><= ==>= (<= E=?==) ? >> >< > ? @=, > [=> ?><= ?[ ><= ? [@>=-?= ? = [>==>. @ ==>@ =[<<< [=, ??< > >>< = <>= ?@?. CE <> ?? <<=>> [==>. C <>><> ?> ?= < > <<> ? = ?= <>> ? = <?=.

[E= ">= @<> > <?@< @<=> [> >?> = ?@< [, > @<=< : <>= ><=<<, =<><, <>= =?= ?><= > ?<?=,> > <= <?=.

II B L( ) ( $( (/($ $ >$ ( %>>)&( (>(..( $.> ( (

1 "( ( ( &.(..(

D <? == >= <>>> ?=?<= =>= < , > Outgoing students, ? <>=orkshops ><-<>= (? ><-=). [ <> ?== ? >?>= <>< <? ?=> <= ? @> <>< [. E 2009-2010, > ? ? <= > ?=. => =<>@ <= <>= >@>= (<?, >, >, >.) ?<> =.

@ > > <> = =<>=, <> ? D$EA <>>?< @. [ > ==> == ?=?< = >=. $?< = ?><= =<>=, = >?>= ?@> << ? &?=. >> ? => 50 \, ? => ? ? ? @.

15



2 A&&(. ( $&&/$*(/(

E <@, ? [>@>= => <== ?< ?< = <-><>= ? = >?>= .[ <=> > ? = >> > = << =?= < [? =< [? ?<. BDE,?> ?, < ?== ? > [?. "=, ?? @< ><> ? == [? <><, [? ,

[? >= [>>, [? ?@<> @, [=> <=. <>< ? [<<@ ?@? >?>= => = >< ? >= <> ?< [.

$?< ? => = >?= > [>< = @ >@, ><= ? [<>= => ><=== ??= =?< = ?=, = <>= ><= ? =?< = ?=>= ?= <= @ >@. '<? ?< = = @= > <=< = <><= ><= = >?>= > ?>?<= O= =>>?<>? @.

3 Q$.> ( .$ ( ( &$( %=

C> >? ?@ =>?> [ >< @, > => ?= =. @> >= >< [ > C<?= ?< = >= <>. = <= <=>> >?>= @= > ?? ==>> X Y [ > = >< = @= ? ? = [. [>==> < ? < ><@

<@. C? >?> == = << = ><@ > = [ = ?<= =?< => ?=?[ 21, @<23 <>= =<= =. [E= <= > [= ? < <>? ><= <>> > = ?<<?<>. I => < ?<= ? =><?>?< <@ <> < > =><?>?< X[=Y, ?< >><=>?<>, > ? >< <--?==, < < C<?=, ? < ? >?>= = <= ?<= < Q>.

!< ? =?> >> @<= = =<@= ? C<?=, ? <= [E= >? =< > ?<= >?>=. C[=> ? > => ? =>> = ?>= <><= < = >?>= [?><= E=. == ? >= ><= == ?= << !D <> ? >@> <== > =>?=. $< >?<, [ < <?> = = <?<= >?<= ?< = >=?><= > ?< [<> ?.

#?>< ? ==> <@>@, [E= @ @ = [? ==> <>?<

[<> ?<= = <-><>=. E >, ?<> [ 2009-2010, > >< < ? ?&?= (= < [? @> @ [?@<=> ">=) =?< <> ? @ = >?>=? ?> ? << . E <= ===< == >?>= > >>< = =>=<>?<= < ==>< [@>< >?> <>. C ==> > ? 1< ==><, =<> < ??= ?=>>= ?< = ==><= =?@>=.

16



L$ $>*( (0 /$?( ( $(0$$

?@ => [E= <>= ? @> =>> = ? @<> <?,?>?< > =>>?> <> >>. =><> <>< =[< via = V?@< <>= >> >< [=> ? <<. @> ? ? =? > >? @< ?<=>@ ><> = => ? = [ <> < = <=>= ><?<=.

I B L( >(.(/( ( (.$ $&$>/(

<> @ = >==>= [=> =?<?< ?, <? ? >? =[=> > = << > =?. I => ==< ?[? <> =< => [?< > ><> <, , [E= ">= <=> <>= ===, = ? O> = @=

(<<= E<=?=) ? ? O> = =>= > = <?<=.= < ?<= ? [E= ><>> = = @ C"& (! A= 1563) > @ C$C ?

>>< <> << I&', == ?[ => =><> <> >< <><>@ = E$&' > = E.

II B L( (.$ $(& .( &..(&> ($.(

= >@>= ><<><=, >?> = ? =?=, => = <<=>= = ==>= <> [E=, = ?<= <?>= => <=>=, <>= < = <=>= ><?<== intuitu personae. <=> ><?<, <>< < = =<@= ??>[<> < < > [=>?< (C<) <= = >?> CA. [ >= = <? @ = >@>= ><<><= > = ><?@ =?@> => < = (<<, >?=,

=?>>=). [E= <> >> ? C> =?>> < ?< << > @>>? (CCD') = < = < = $= <.

III L( (.$0 $(& .( /.( &>&0/(

= ? =?= => ?= = = >@>= <> (<> < = <=== [<> =><?<, <>> ? ?<=, <> >?) > <<. => [E= @<== <<>= @ = ? : = ==> [==, < ?@<>?< = =>>= <== > ? <<<>>?< <=>?= @ >>. = >@>= << @ = ><<== ( [<>>?<)<=>> > =.

17



18



L$ $>*( (0 /$?( ( (.$00(0$0$.(

[>@> ><> [E= ">= => @<=> @, ?[ =[== << ? <>, > ? <= ? = >?>=. [ < <L>< = = > = <>=><>=. !=, ?<, [=> = >< =><> <, = @<=>= <<=, = ? ? =?> <>> ? <<= ?<= ? ><>?.

I => << ?, ? = [, ==?< @<>> > >< <>=><>=. [>@> ><> => =?@ < ? <= 80 % ? =<@ = >?=, < ? =?@ > ?.

CA < =?< = <>= ><>= = =?> => <<> ><>. = =>= > = <?<=<> @?> ?< << >, = >>= [><< > = ><>= ??= = ?@> <.

G> ?< > = . E == @<=, [ = [@>> > ?<= = =>= ><?<= ><<=. # > > ??= >?>= >= = = <><= (?@<=> C<> '?=, ?@<=> H? C, ?@<=> >? ?@ B?, ?@<=> = A<=$? ? !?).

> < ==>> = >?>=. E , [ => @> <<> ?<[@ [@= (== 40 60 X=<>>=Y >< 2006 > 2009), < ? ?>= >= ?[ =,> = [E ? << E<=?=, ? =>< > = $= <, ? ?< [?(27 X><>=Y 2009-2010) @ = ?>= ?= <= E?<. [E= ">= == 38 @>= @= ?@<=>= ><<=, ?>> < ?= ? ?< < ?= 2006. E = ? <>> ?> ?= = = @= => ? >@= ?< <>? [? ? ><<. [ <=?=?<= XO= >= > <><>Y ; ? [>< ? ?> = =>>?>= ><<= (D$EA <>>?< @ @ [?@<=> , B?, D$EA =< > =>< ><> @ B??=-D==?, A).

19



20



21

I B L( ?/( *$$ ( ( .$*(

==> [<=> [>==> > ? = E$A ?< = = [<>>?< @??= <>?<>= ?< >< = >= ?[?<> <<> @ ?@<=><.

<>?<, < =>< < ?>?<, ? >?> ? = >>= ? <>. I ?><> =?< [= = =<@= > ? <= [>==>. I << > ?> = <>= ? CA?? = <>. A? ? >=, = E= > > ?=?<= <= <>?< : =>, =><>?<,<== [<> =><?<S [>? <>?<, => ?= 13 =, ?? ?=?<= = <=.

CA > 24 <= @ @<== ?<= > : 6 =>= ?= ?< ><= =, 6 @= ?=?< ? =, 6 <=>= ><?<= = < !CC ?< ? =, 2 <<=>>= = B>= [E=

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

>>?< ? < ? <=> ><?<.= CA = E= =>, < = =>=, ? C$ ? << = == ? CA = ><=.

[E= ">= = C$ ? == : = = >?= (CE) > = <= =>= ( 10 20)=> = < CA ? ?> ? ?@<=><, = =[?> =?< ? =<@ = >?= > ?<>< >, > = =>? (C&) = ?< ><= =. <=> ? = == == [?>< => ?< >=< <>. E ?><, ?< <=>< = >>= =>?<> C$, = ?== => <?= ? = < === <. D= === >> ==> <<> === : == <<?>> = =>=, == AEE$$ ( ?< ? =), >.= ?== ?[? <>= 2010, [E= = ? = @ >?>. [E= > ?==@ = =>= <@?= < <>> ? => > >? <>< (C'$) > > [> =?<> (CH&).

C>> <=> Q < ? =>> = ?@? ? (@<< 2009) > ? <

<?@> = <= > == <<=>>=. = =>@ = <<< [?@<=> ?> [E= @< = <>= =, <@> = <?>= ?@< <>@> ?<>= >=. ?<> [<< < [E= ">= >< = [=> <>> ? <>?< = [=>>?>, => <> P = = => ??<[? <><=, ? => >< <= ? =?< <=> <> = = ?><= =>?<= ( => > <=>= ><?<=? CA, = = >?=). U =?<, >, <O <>> ? <>?<= <><,? ==?<> ? <> < = = =>= <>@= > => << @ <>?< ?><?@<> =>=>?<. <=> > ?< [@< ?> >< <>?.

& [E= ">= [ = <> < [>==>, == ? ?>= =><>?= : ==< [>> = <<= [=> << < CE > ?> << ?< ><> << > < CA, = @<>> @ < >?>. $< ?<=, ><<>? ?@ , ? ?<> = = @<== =>=, ?>> ><? ?< =><>?. E > < ? <<> ==>> [?>@?> ?< [A<=. [E= =[

<< ? <> [>==> = < [<> ? < ><> ?< = @<=< =<= ><<== @ = <><= ?@<=><= > = <><= =?= > >?= > ?<>< > = = >< @> =?> > ><>.

L$ *(0$0&(



22

II B L( .$*(, .( >(.(/( ( .$ $.> ( ?/( )/$ (( &//&$

[>==> =[=> > [? =<@ [<> > ?> = 2001. E =>> <<==(<=, = >?= > ?><= 325 000 \ 2006 522 000 \ 2010), => = ??<[?

= <== ? ==?<> L><= [V?@< > => [= = = > <=? <>?= >?<?= [>==>, = [=>, << (<= C<) > [=><>.[=>> = ?@? => > [ [? ==> ?= <> > <<>, ?>=> = = <?<=> = (K ?< >? > = ><= ?>>, <=> ? <=? =?<= ? =>@? <=? < [ > ><@ @ 300 = =?>= < ?<), < [= [?= <>?< @> = 'IC < =>< >?>. => = >?='M, ? =< @>?> ([?><= >== => =) 2011, > >. & ==>[>?<= [@?> <=> < <<, = ?>= =>> ?< <>>< <>< [= =><O>= =. <> >? ? <= >< ?<?>? > ><>> [= > > > => = V?@<.

III B L$ .( ( /$?( (/., ( /$( $.$$.( ( ( *( (

(&( +/$(= >= <==> <<> @ @? [>@> [>==>, @ 45,5 E'$' >>?<=

?< = =>=, 39,25 ?< = B>= 2009. I => >< > ? = >= [> = @? <= [=>> = = ?@? ? ? <<=? ? <==> => = =?<= ?=, ? <>> [>?>= > ? <?@? = <>= = <>= =. A= [E= ->- Q ?=>< ? ? ==>= ? === > == ?= <= ? < = <= ><@ ==. C> ?=>>= @?= [= ? === > @ =?< = =>= == <> (=?@ [?> ? [) > <= >< = = <<?>>= =?< = <==?<= <<= [>==>. <> == =< = = ?>= [>==> (30 %) => ?= @< ? = [?><= E=. C>>== =< @? > <<==@> ?== : 831 000 \ 2006, 998 000 \ 2009, = == <?<> =?< ?> << <<=>> 69 000 \ 2006 > 136 000 \ 2009. [ = V?@<

? ==> < <= < >?> ? < = <?<>= = <== ><>?=. <<?>> = =>= === <=> = <= ><=< = ?> =

= > > = = <<?>= < [><@> [? == <<?>> ? <=@<=. D= ==, [ = = CDD ?= ? ?< ?< <>= == =>=@><= = < [? ?@> > ?= < >?>, > =? < = ><>?= ==> >= <>?<= =?< = === ?< =?= [>> = == [@< <?<= = >>?<=(<> = >?=, =<@ <>? > ?> < ). [><> = >= <L> <?==.

C> ?< ?<<> >< <= ?=> < = <=>@= <>= <><> : ?= [? [>= => <= = = ?> = @<, >> < = B>=. & [E= <?@ = >[><> ?@? >= (72 % = =>= > > <?@= ?= 2002), = ? ?<<> =><?@< >< = [>= [> ? < <> [? >< [>> =?< ?

<> <><>.

= =>= <><= CH& > C'$ => = <?= ?= ? = < . $?< CH&, ?>?? => >??<= ?<= [<>, >?> <@>. = <<=>>= ? <= =>= = =>= => ? ?< <O ?<<> >< ? <= =<>. & ?, [=>> = =?@? ? > ? = ? [ => > <@ > = <= =?< ? =><== ? ><@. C <= <@ ?== ? ?>< < : [>? = ? > ?< <=> >>= [>> [? ? @@> ? =<@<> << > ? [ <.

[E= [ = < <= < ===> ? @> =?>. C> < ?> ?< [<> ?@ <= << > ?=?<= =>= <@> >> <?> (<==?<= <>?=, > [? ==> == [== >=, @>> >?<,<?> = = =>>>, >> [?>=> = ><=<>= ? > = = ?, ><>

? @> =?> = <> = >=S). I => >< >O> ?< ><< ? > = >=><<==.



I" B L*$$ ( .( .$*( ( .$ .( %*>$( ( )$&?(

[<=> ?><, = ? ?, => == ><=. <>?<, @ <=>? CA > <>< =><>@ > <, = <= <>>= ?><= <=>= ? CA ?< ><@>= @> [>< ?>= =?= = <==>. #?>< = <= =, = == <> = ==

<= (<= >>?<=) > = <= <>= ? >@>= [=> > << (=== > >=S).= <==?<= ?><= => =>>?= < = >>= =><= > = <==?<= <<= (@>= << > @>= @<== === @ = >@>= ??=, <>= =<>, > [<>==,<?>= = ==> [==S). > ? CA <> =?<>?> =?< = = = ? =>=> ? ><= ?= ? >?>=. = ?>= >?= => <@= => ?< > <<=> = ?>= [= > ><O => =?=> @=.

<>< =><>@ > <, <== = <==?<= ?=, [=> ?== ? =<@ <.E => =? @< > [<>?<, ? = =?=> ? < > [>==>. &? =<@ < = ==, = ?><= =<@= ==> = = ? => ?>= ?[<= @=? =<@ <. C =<@ @ [ > (> ? =>< = =) = < ?===>> = ==> < [.

> <=>> ? ?> <> (B$) 2011 = @> CA => < > >. B$ =[@ ? ? ?= 3,3 !\. >> =>< <<=>, <>>, 70 % >>.

D?= [< 2008 <? < ? > [?>, [ <><?@ = >= [?>?><= ?<=. [=>> = = ?@? ? ><L = <<?=== =?< = == >> (?=, >> >, <=>>= >> ? <). C=- > ?> 814 146 \ 2008 1 195 547 \ 2010 = <==> ??<[? L><==. = <>= >>?>= (<= == =<) => === 1 440 00 \ 2006 2 030 000 \ 2009.

E ? < <=> <>> =?< [> ?, [= =?>>=, =<>- ?=?= < <= <?< >, ><< =?< <=> ? = <= ?=. &= << < > >> ? <=> >> ><, [ > ><<< ? <=>< = <=, < , =[==> = <?>= = @ [?><= >==>= ?=. I =<> ?== ==<

>< = ?>= ?><= < [= = ?>= = == < <>> ! 9-1(= [ < ? <<= ?<?= [@=>==>=) > [< ? ? =>< ? [>>> = =<@= =><=, <>?< =?< = >? [?> <>>= > == ? = ><==>.

= <==?<= >= ? > [? <<> ?>>? => @= ? << ? >> >> ??> : 728 000 \ ?< << = ?>< >@ [ 2011, ?< ? ?> 3,33 !\. C=<>= ?<?= => ?<= ><= =?@ =? > [= > ?@> ><?< =?< = >?[?> [= ? ?>. I => ==< [>< ? = < =, = <<> ? ><= = ?>=><>?=, = >>= ? ?<<> < [> [? <>> = < <>= [>==>. I@> ?== @<< [>> ? Q>= <> = ? >> ? <@> <= ? <> [>==> : < , >? <@> =?< = <>>= ><>?=, ? ? >> [E=, 4 % =?> <L> ><> =?=-@?.

= <==?<= = ==> = ? => <==, ? ?=>< [>><> [ > <?==> = ><> = @. I @> < << > [= = >==>>?>= ? < >> <=>> > <=<@< ? <> = <==?<= ?@<>?< = Q>= <>=,[?>> ?= ?[ =[> [? =>?< ?<<> > ?<> > [>@> ?> >< =?= 'A.

" B L$ .( //%.?( : *(, /$($&( ( >(.(/( $/(

[E= ">= == [? >< < ?, <<> [>>, >?> > <<?. [, ?<<? >?>= = >@>=, => <= ? >>= <= < ? ==<. >> < < =>@>= = [=> > = =<@= =?<>= ; = => ? =>=, ? <><= <<, = = == > <>. G< ? ==> =><?> <>?, [ == @=>==?<= (2,5 = = =?<= ><?<=), => 15 ^ < >?>, < ?== <?<> = <=

?< = ><= > ? ><<== >>> ==. >> < ? @<=> [== >= @<=>= ?>= <>?= = < [=> > << >< <>>?<.

23



> > = ><< = =<@= =><>= = ? =? >> = = <<<= ? > = ?= ? > =. $?< <= =><>, <=?> >> =<= ? <==[>>, << < [?< = =?<= > ?< = >= >< =<@= = ? < [=[? ? (<O ? ?<<> ?< >? ? [= <=>?<>). C[=> ? ?> <,==>> ? ?>= [<<> [? ?@ ?>.

C> >? @<= <> ? >>, = ><>= = = <>= [=>>= > === ?<< = <=>><=, = > [ = < > <. = <<= = => (?, <), <= ? << > >>, > >< >=?< ? >> ? >< 2003-2006 = < ' 20001. ?>> = =?<= == == = >= >?= > = ?== (?@<>?< = ?>=>?<= ><?<=) = ?=> > =>? < = === ?= ?= >?= (<> = >= < ) = ? >> =>=>, @< <?> = >=.

"I B L( >(.(/( ( .$ &$$&> $>$.$ $ (&( (/(..(( ())&$&> ( .$&

> [?>@?> => ?< > ?= =>>, << = ? = : => ?><, <= ><O =>, > [@?> = =>=.

"II L( /$0$*(/(0 ( .$ $.>

[ > = >< [? -E'$ ><O?< =>, ><> < = <= >= ==>= [? => <=. C>, <?> [>?<= [=> = ==>>=, [>==> ==> = >? < <>=. < ?> [=> = ?= <=, = [<> <=?< << ? <<> [>@>= ><= > => =?<.

E ? < = ? ?> = >= > ><O ><, [=> = < < ===> [ [>==>, <= @> ? [ <> < == ??= (DF). C= ? ?<<> >< <<==@> ><?>= < ?@ >

= < = == = > < ><O?< =>. C= <<= ?<<> ?== <>< <?==> < >> >? ? > [> [? << < : <=> << > <<>< >> ? <>.

24

1 >> ><? 2000.



L$))/$0 ( .(0> ( .>$%.(/(0$ $( 0( .( ( &//0&$0

[>>> [ > = >>, <?@? = ? =[=<>, >?> [> >< <> @?< = <?==>=, => =?= < = <>= >?<=. $?< ?>>, > = @? <<< >> ??> ? =? <@< <? = ? ?<= = <<= = ><@.

D= > =<>, ?<=?> ?<= [ >< <= ? = [ ? <= = ?<= ( >><, X?< ?@<> [=>?<Y <? = =<>=), <> ? <> [>==> > =?<>?>? ?> >< > ?<<> <>>< << == [>.

?@> ?= < ?<< [<>= <@= > >< ?<=?@ > ?< < =>>??< [?< < @>?< ?> ><.

A@ = ?@? >>, [E= ">= ?= ? >> @=? ><= <>, ? ><?> = [= ?<>= ? <> [=> >? > ?@<> =?< = @<>. Livre de l$#cole d$architecture de

Nantes < > <<? [<> =><?> >> >>, ? = =>= = =><.

= >= = <> =?@ = >?>= > [= [?< = O= = ? [=[? =<@>< = ?=.

">= ? [? >> <? ?< = <?>= [ [ = < > <=.E <=> [>?.

25



26



27

[ > =?<?< [<>>?< ">= (E= ">=), >==> ? <>< =><>=?= >?> ? =>< C?>?< > C?>, ? 800 850 @=, > 130 ><>= 1< .E @< ? > O= [<>> < . [? => <> 45,5 E'$, >>?<=> ===, > > ><@< 53 =>= ><>?=. <= B>= > 39,25 E'$. ?> =?> =[@ 3,5 !\ ?< 2009.

[E= ">= ? = <<= = <= ?>>=, > ? ?<= : [=>> =? ?@? >> (18 000 2 & ?< 12 000 2 =?< ?>), <<? =?= <? =>=<>>?<?, ?<= > @<>?, ? V?< >< >= ([] ">=), > [=<> [ = [=> =?<?< > <<, @ <?@>, > =

?@<>?< =?< = ? =?= > >?=. C= ?>>= [> = < <?> >?= ?<= >=,= [<> = <>= <== >, =?< <? >= , <?==> <> > = =<>= ? @> < < >= @> >< =?=.

G< == <><= <<, [E= =? =><?< = <= ?<=<= (&$I, &H&) @>= <><> @ [?><= =>>?>= =>?= = ? >= =?< = >=, [<>>?<, [?< > =, ? =[=<@> ? V?< = ? [? @> =?>. E > ?<=?@< = >> @ <@=>> >?=>, = <>?= > = >= >, <>> ? <?@> == >=,=[?@<< ?= <=?> =?< ? <> ?< > ><> > [ < > ?[><@< >>.

[>@> >< << = ? = =>= ?> ? <O ==>, <

[? =>>?> >, <= [<< ? < <> > > >?, =>? > <==, < ?>, ><= @<=, ?=> ? < @> O= > = ?= ?<=?= @ = =[?<= > [?@<=>. #?>< ?<=?> >> <> > >> ?>?=> = =, [E= >>> < @ == <><= ? @?> <=>@ == <>=, ==> = >?>=.

D= < ? =>>?> >, = <=== >= > =? < = <<= <>>= ?< =><?<? ?@< <>>> ?<=?@< = ><= === ==>= @?= ? E= : [=>, << > ?= ?>?<. [<> [? <> [>==> @<=> => [ > ==<>= <= > ><>= @<> ? <>>< =< = = >??<= >< >= ?< ??@ > = @> ? > >< > [? >< =?=-=>= (= >?=, ?<=>> ><>=>).

I B L( ) =<> <?== = [@<> ?, ><<>< > =?, @<= < ? =>

> ? >> <<?= ?@<>= =?< @ ;

?> << < ? =>>?> > = =>= = E= ;

<=> > ? => << = <==?<= ?=, >= < > [ ;

=> ?>< > < = ;

?> <>? > ?> ?>.

C&. ( (&//$$



II B L( )$%.(

== [> ><> = =>= > << > <> ;

=?= = ?>= =?@ > [> = >?>= ;

[= >? ?>, >> >< [@?> [=> ;

? <=>@ = > [<> > = <?@> ;

== [= = <>= <<>= <= <==?<= >=.

III B L( (&//$$

F< =<> ? ?@< =><>@ == ? ?= < ?@< >? (CA,@-<=>=, == > ===) ;

!>>< ? > = ?>= [@?> [=> > = ?= ;

<?< = <><= ? =? ?> <> @ [?><= >==>= > << ?>? =>? ?< [ ;

F@<=< ? >?> = @ [>==> ;

!>>< = ?@? >>= ? =<@ ? @> <=> [ ;

!? <=< = <><>= ?>?< ??= <<>=, >> [><>.

28



29

AADE A<>> O [>>A<= A [@?> << > [=> =?<?<A' A<> > >?= <<=>>

BBDE B?<? = @=BDIB>= ($<=) >?, ?<=, =><>=, >=, > ?@<<= =<@B$ B?> <>

B'& B<@> > =?<?<CCA C= [=><>C< C??> [<> < < > [=>?<CAE C= [<>>?<, [?<= > [@<>CCD' C> =?>> < ?< << > @> >?CE C= = >?=C< C>< << >? [<>>?<CH& C> [ > =?<>CH C>< =>< ?@<=><C"& C>< > << =>?C$E C== <>< [>==>

C$ C== > <<C<== C>< << =?< [= =< > [@<> ?<C<?= C>< < = V?@<= ?@<=><= > =<=C& C= =>?C'$ C> >? <><CE C= @ >?>

DD (!D) D><>D D<> [<>>?< > ? ><D$EA DO << ? = [<>>?<DF D<> < = = ??=D&A DO ==> > [<==> architecture

EEC E=>-<?<EC" >< ">=EC'& European Credit Transfer S"stem (==> ?< [?>= [=> >==

><=<= [? = [?><)ED ><E= > =?<?< [<>>?<E"&BA"! > = ?-<>= ">= ><E$A >==> ? <>< =><>E$CI >==> ? <> ><?E >==> ? <>< ?=>< > <

E$&' >==> ? <>< =>? > >?E'$ ?@> >= E'$' ?@> >= ><@

L( ( *.(



FFIF $ F= ><<== <> = <=== <=F F<> <<

GG<= G<? [>? > << =? <>>?<

HHCA H=>< > ?>?< <>>?<=HD H>> << = <<=H!#"$ H>> L><= [V?@< = <<

II&' I=>>?> << == > >?= @

L (!D) 1/2/3 (!D) 1< , 2 , 3 ? =, >= ?<=, ><>=C$C <>< >< = >= > ?===!D -=><-><>[ [@<=> ">= A<= != ($<=)

M! (!D) !=><!1/!2 (!D) =>< 1< , 2 !CC !=>< C?>?< > C?>

P$<= $O << > [=> =?<?<

S&H& &= ?= > ==&$I &= ?< [?<&'A &= > >?= ?< [<>>?<&>? &= > >?= [@<> ?<

'IC '= [<> > ?>'$CA '<= > <>?= > <>>?< > ?<'A ' =?< @?< ?>

!

E > [=>! > > <<

"AE > = ?= [<AEE$$ > = >?=, = <= <=== ? ?= <==' = > ><<><=

#* Wireless Fidelit" (F> == )

30



31

O%($ (&(



32



33



34



O*$$ ( .'>$.$

[@?> [ > =?<?< [<>>?< ">= ? ? = 6 ? 7 @< 2011. >[@?> >> <= < C? Jacquier, <>?< << ? C"&, ! '< R 5206 E"& .

O0 $&> < .'>$.$0 :

J? Chazal, >?> =>< 2, E= &>->

CN Diez-Pastor Iribas, <==?<, ?@<=> IE &@ (E=)

$<< Lajus, <>>-?<=>

$ Louguet, <==?<, E=

$ Paillet, <>?< < = =<@=, ?@<=> !>< 2

$>< Garnier, ? =>?, > C>< Dhaussy, < <>, <<=>> [A<=.

[@?> <> =?< [>> [>==> ? > P = <>== > > <==.

D Lecointre ==?< $A#.

Aeres s1 Ensa Nantes 2011

Documents

Transcript of Aeres s1 Ensa Nantes 2011