8/16/2019 AERES S1 Ecole Centrale Marseille

1/42

Section des établissements

décembre 2011

Rapport d'évaluation de l’ÉcoleCentrale de Marseille

8/16/2019 AERES S1 Ecole Centrale Marseille

2/42

%

8/16/2019 AERES S1 Ecole Centrale Marseille

3/42

8/16/2019 AERES S1 Ecole Centrale Marseille

4/42

%

8/16/2019 AERES S1 Ecole Centrale Marseille

5/42

4

III @ D& " / " */ < /* & " *= & %& (& */ %& < "# * & & 27

1 = & % * / " */ $/ * & & " " & & * & % GEC 27

2 & (& */ < * */ & & %& & /* & %& $/ < & $& & & & "$& 28

3 & (& */ * " $*= & * & ("(& " / "# & & & " $& * *$" */ %& " " * < %& $/ & . 28

I! @ D& %/ *& " * / *" "#/ %& " &$ %& $& 29

1 D& / & * * " / "* & & * " */ * /#* *= & $/ & & %& * & %& ECM 29

2 L" (& */ % * & %& C); &" G/ #& 29

3 L& /+& * /#* *& %& " " $& & B&$ & & 30

L " * " */ %& *%& * < %& < "# * & & " & " / * * &%& $/ *$" */ 31

C/ $ */ & &$/ " %" */ 33

I @ L& /* / 34II @ L& /* "*# & 34

III @ L& &$/ " %" */ 34

L* & %& *( & 35

O# & " */ % %* &$ & 37

O (" * " */ %& < " " */ 41

8/16/2019 AERES S1 Ecole Centrale Marseille

6/42

5

!^ > = " (EC") = O -=N = F = > ? N > =O K ^ > N=N ^ = N= " (EGI"), E C NN = 2003 ? >

^ = N= = @ (E# " > ?- , E A N K ^ = N CN == ), = C> = ^ = N CN == ) = "N = @ (E "2, > = ^ = N

@ = N N = 2004 ^ > ?N ^ = N= " (E I"), N > > > , = 2010, 110

8/16/2019 AERES S1 Ecole Centrale Marseille

7/42

6

8/16/2019 AERES S1 Ecole Centrale Marseille

8/42

7

! ?> @ ^EC" ^ >= = = = >== < = N N, ^ == 2003 ? N > ^ = N= N = ?> >= ^EC" , ^ ?

'E >== A -" *= N.

I @ / & *& %& &$)& $)& "%/ < : %& < * & %& " * <I

8/16/2019 AERES S1 Ecole Centrale Marseille

9/42

8

C ?> @ K N = ^EC" > > = @ > > , ? >< = ? = , ?> ^EC" , ? EC >= =N , N? K ? ? O N@ < = = > = N > O

, EC ^EC" >= N K > > =

!^ > < = K N N >= = > @ > = @ K

> < >= ^ = N= N=N , > ? ? = N, K = ^EC N O = > < >=, ^N > > -K- ? = ^A -"= < = = = ?> = @ N ? > < 2 , < N = N ^A -" ( = = >= ?> = > > = = N ? ^N > (?> = >

> @ , > = > < >= , > < = = ? N ? ? > > = . E > > > P < > N = = >=

?> >== = @ ^EC", ? , ?> >== >= = > @ .

III @ D& / $& %& "(* * < %& " / * * & %& &$)& $)& $/ ? &

$= > ^ = > @ ? >= ?> = > N ?^N = K => > > , = ? >>?N >= = @

> > , = => >< = >= =N , = N >?? = ?!^N < = ? N< @ >< = => ^N >=><

?? @ N ^ = > < @ ?> > = = > N = = >= > ^A -" , > N N ? C#' , < = =

= > >< = = = , ?> ^EC" = < = >= >= K ^ = = = ( = ?> =

=>< > > > >= . ! @ ^N< < = (150 _ >= 90 _ @ ^ N N =@ = N > ) ^ = ? > @ ? ^EC" = < O > >= ( >= , ) >= ? N> ? = . ! ?

N N >= > >= (DGG) > > > K N N< = N = ? ^EC" >= >= .

X > , ?> @ < = EC, => , A >= >= N > = >= ^N > , > > @

>= N < = ? = . > > , ^N < = ?N , = ? = . = =>= K >= R ^ =

>< = => = , ^EC" N > ? > = >= ?> = >= ? > >= = @ , ? >

8/16/2019 AERES S1 Ecole Centrale Marseille

10/42

1 30 % EC >= >= =N ? > Z .

9

! ?> @ ^ = >= K N > N > >= N ?>N< @ (C'C ) > N N >= C#' . I =^ < = = ?> ^ O < =

N ? < > N , ?> N > = > > @ >> ^N . @ ?N = ?>= N ?> => EC

? @ N [ N K N\, < = @ ^ = O > < = > > N = >= =^N < = , ? > < N EC >= ^N > , < N < = ^ =^ = = < =1, ? = ? @ @ ^N < = =^ ? N ? > ^N =

. D O = >< = > = > > P < = ? ? < = ? N ? >= = ^N @ = N >?? = ? @ =>= >= R N @

< > > ^ O >== @ N.

8/16/2019 AERES S1 Ecole Centrale Marseille

11/42

10

8/16/2019 AERES S1 Ecole Centrale Marseille

12/42

11

B = @ ^ > ? N = >= N >= , ^EC" = >= O ? [ >= =N > >= N . E O = = = = = < ? >= >< = O< = < Q ^N=via C = " => >

(C"' ) @ ?> ? >== ^N@ ? < = ? >? = >< = (34 = ). !̂ N > = ? ? >= < => = > N N > >= [C = I==> >= A\ =

N N > C = .

!

8/16/2019 AERES S1 Ecole Centrale Marseille

13/42

12

8/16/2019 AERES S1 Ecole Centrale Marseille

14/42

13

I @ L& * / "(& %& / & %& / " */! > < >= K C = " < @ N ? ^ N N > >=

GEC.

E= 2007, >= N = >== @ , ^N > = = > < >= ^ = N= , N ? O N > = => ?

E >=M> > , < = ? , = > = >= ?N > @ = ? > > < >= => = N 2009, N=> N = > ^ O < = ( ==N 1 2 >= = > <

3 < = ? K = N 2011-2012).

1 F/ " */ %& * (< *& , / " */ * * *" & / " % < %*"

!^> = >= ?N > @ K ^EC" = N > < >= ^ = N= = =, >= 147 ? R= ^> 600 = = > <

^N = (217 => = = = 2010).

D ? N >= ^N > , N= < = >= >= = N ^ >= = N= = @ , >= ^ < > < >= ^ = N= ^EC" ?> N N< = = : ^ = N =

?> = = @ = N ^A -" .

!^ > < = > < >= K < = => < =2010-2011) @ > = = < ("2) = > O< ==N = @ ?

> > (15 % ? R= = >= N = (8,4 %). ! = > < >=Z = < = ?> N ? EC N< @

> ?>= = < > N ^N > . ! = < ? > >= > < >= ? ? O N O = N= : >=

, = > > = O< > O< ==N ( = >= 20 N O ? =), ? > = @ ^N > > N , = >= > = ? >

= = < = "2.

! N O >= >= K ^ =@ P == C>=

N > > ^N , 13 % = ^ ? < = K ^ =@ P 70 %.

! > >= ^ = = ??> = K ^ >= > ^

8/16/2019 AERES S1 Ecole Centrale Marseille

15/42

1 > : N < = .

! ? > >== >= > < >= >= = = N N K ^EC". C ? = = , = ?N > = = > < >= = N= , >??> = @ ^N > = > >= ?>

8/16/2019 AERES S1 Ecole Centrale Marseille

16/42

1 ! N N = C I > < = < < 14 < = = = ? .

15

!^N > >= < =@ ^ N, N K = < N < = K ^ =>= >= N = . E= , > < = >= N > =N >T - = > = ^N > > ?> = , ^ > < @ [N > =

= N = >= (90 % N O == = ^ N >= @ ACA). E= =, ^>= N ? N O : O N=N > < >=, N< @ > , ?> N > > = ^

> = = >= . ! N O ? N = K ^N > >= > ?> = ?? > >= ^N > , ?> >= N ? O C GE.

! > >= N ? > > = N > ^ = N= N=N N ^> > <^ = N= > > < >= ? >?> N = < > N >>- N N = N ^A -". ! >= ? ?> = ? ? = N >= N =N = > >= ^N > , ? ? > ?>= ?

? N = = > ? O = . I ^ ^ = ?> >== < = = = ^> N >= , = < >= > ^ ?? = = GEC.

! = N= = = >= O > < = = ? N N< GEC, ?N??> = ? >== N, ? = ? < = = ^> > O< ==N ( < , ? > >= @

? = ? < = Kl’ @ >= > = = ? >N? = = = >= < = = ?N N (45 % = = < = ),

(20 % = = < = ), ^ = N= , >= ? > (10 %), = = = >=? > ? >== , ?> . ! = = < = > > = < 8 O< N > => > = N, > = < 9 ? > ^ ?? > >= < =

! N >= ?> < 8, 9 > 10 ?> ?N > N< @ > = =

> K ^ = = >= .> >== = , = K = = ? < O ==N , K > =

==N @ K = = . ! = > > >= = > N = (12 % O< ==N = 2009, 21 % = 2010). I = N O > O< ==N (34 = 2009-2010, 48 = 2010-2011). C N >?? < = > > ?? > K = >= ? K = ? > = ?N = = = = ? , > ? ?

= N= 1 ; ^ ? , ^EC" ? N N< = ^ ? R= =N , = = >= ? > >== @ ^N

2 M" & & %/$ / "

! = > < >=- >= N ? = ? < = = > O< ==N >S, = 2010-2011, < = >= < = , > N > = ? = :" N< @ ?? >= ;I= N= N >=>< @ = = O ;"N = @ , @ I= N= ;

@ , ?N N $? @ > >= @ ;" > = =>N >= @ ;GN= ? > N N ;C < ;

= >= = N ;I= > < @ .

8/16/2019 AERES S1 Ecole Centrale Marseille

17/42

1 ! C>= N = = N > .

16

! N? >= N O = < = < = = < ^ = N= N >=(11 N O 34 = = "2 = 2009-2010 ; 20 48 = 2010-2011) : = N =

?N >= ^ = >= ? > >== .

*= >= = >= N N =N ?> ?N > 2008-2011 = N ^A -"

N ? @ ^ O "2 : >= >= ^ = ? >= ^ , O =! ?>= < >= > N > < >= K ^N >?? N N ?> = = @ ?? > ? ? = . ! ?>= >= = @ N O >= = K N < = = > > .

> < >= N=N , > N< @ = @@ ^ > = ? >?> N K ^N > > = "2, = > = ?N >= = = ? >

N< @ = = N .

3 P /+& %& %< & / & & %& / " */

> < >= = = N= = = ? > N, =>< ? > > < >= > = > , = > N ? ? > = >= @ =@ == . ! > < >= ? =

N >= => > < = ? R< = ^ = > >=, K < , ^ ??>

8/16/2019 AERES S1 Ecole Centrale Marseille

18/42

1 C>= = >= = N= = @ F = .

17

E= @ >= = ^N > >= ? > N ? < ^ ?N < = ^N >= = = < = . C > < < = =@ P ,

= N ? O N O N N N . D M>= ? = > < , ?O N = N > = = >= = ?? > N, ? = >=/> EC >= N .

E= > O< ==N , N O ?? > >= ( N ) >= >= ? N = N CE, @ > >= ?> @ ==N = . ! =

>= > < >=, @ = >= K ^ >= >= = .

E= < O >=, ^N > K > N O = < =^N O - = N= ( > < = >= K ^N > ), N @ C#I F1 = >=

> = > < @ . ! > < = >= > < >= K ^ = >= = = ? N=> >= : = N @ I= = , N N

O < = >= ? - > < = = .

> @ >= = , = =, @ N ^N >= N = , >= ? N

?>= ^*E.

8/16/2019 AERES S1 Ecole Centrale Marseille

19/42

18

8/16/2019 AERES S1 Ecole Centrale Marseille

20/42

L" " > P = = > ? N N ^ < = >=.

"P< ^ = ?> = ? = > > ? , N N = >= >= ^N > >= = ?> >== Q ^ = < => N ) = . !^ < = >= ? N > ? = = = ? < O ==N , N = > O< ==N = O ==N => = = >= 74 000 _ K N? = 14 ( ?> , , > N, = >= ? > .). C N? >= N N N N N ?

CAC 13, NN = N = N = CA > = < =C ? @ = ? < ? CA ^ = >= R ^ >= N . < N = = K ^EC", = = ^ = @ > = = = > >= . C

N N . !^N > >== Q ^ = = < < > ?> >= N >= > < < = ?>> > @ ^ =^ ? > = = > .

!̂ N < = N >= >= @ N = =>= > >= > = N = (F DIE) K 14 _. ! F DIE ^EC" > =N K > = =

@ > >= ? N = = ?> > = ? > , = >= N N ? > > @ O CAC 13. C N > >= ?> < = K

*= < >= = O = = ??> = > >= , => = ^N > , > = >= = = ( N

= = (CE). I ? = = @ > ^EC" > ? >N = > , > >= N = > ^" .

II @ D& %* / * * * * " / " *& < %*" & %& < "# * & &C>

8/16/2019 AERES S1 Ecole Centrale Marseille

21/42

!^EC" ?> O = >= = >= > C'$* , < >= @ = N > = =

8/16/2019 AERES S1 Ecole Centrale Marseille

22/42

L" " = = ^EC" = N < >= , = = @

: < > N , = N > > >= = C ? = = , >= >= >== Q , = = ? > , ^ = N > >= N K

^ = = N = @ (A -" *= N Z A"*), >= > =?> K ^N = K ^EC" ^> >= ^ = = = => > < ^ = K ? 70 000 N = 4 500 EC.

! >= ? ^ = = < = ?N < ^>= = N , = ^ = 'E N = = ? = ? N < =

= @ ^EC" < , = => >= >=, = > < ? = < O N > > < >= ^ = N= , > = > = <= ^A - =- > = ^A "N , ^EC" ? ? K = ?? > < = ^N >1 =

K > ^ = = N = = ? = [ > A"*\ ^ < = >= C > > >=, @ ? = > ^ > < N = >= < = , ?> N >

>= >= ^ = > >=

8/16/2019 AERES S1 Ecole Centrale Marseille

23/42

22

8/16/2019 AERES S1 Ecole Centrale Marseille

24/42

L" " @ >= = = >= ('I) ^EC" = < = > = N >> :

?> @ >= 1 ? > [C = N =\ ;

?N N , = @ N> ? @ ^N > , @ >=>= N N > ?> >

8/16/2019 AERES S1 Ecole Centrale Marseille

25/42

24

E= @ >= = N = = = = = , ^EC" = = = == @ ? > = N N = , ?> = 30 _. ! N = = O

K N > = : O ? ^EC ^EC" ? > = ?> N = = < = >> = = >= . C = K N = = >= ^N < =

? = < >S, >

8/16/2019 AERES S1 Ecole Centrale Marseille

26/42

25

!^EC" < = Y = > = = @ ? < < > > > N = @ >= = = > >= >= ??> .

I @ /%& %& (/ & " $& * " / * & " $ "(& *%& * "* &.!^EC" N ? = N ^ = > = ? >

, >= = = >= , >=, ? = , O< ^ = > < >= C N@ ? >= >< N N , @ N = @ < = ^ = >

. I > = R N >= N >= > N . ! N=N > = , >> >== < = .

! >= ^ < = >= N = @ > ? = ; >= ? N = N ?> ? >== N N . E= = @ ^E C , ^N > ?> N < = ^ = >= =N . !^EC" N N N = = >= ? >? K ^N > : N= N? > >== ?> ? , @ N = > , C>< N ^> = >

< < => = ??> = K ^EC" = >= ? > ? , @ ^ K N = N

! >< N = @ ? (C ) ^ N = , = 2009 2010, =@ > ? =. E= = , N N (CH ) = ^ N = @ ^ = > = 2008, > = 2009, = N = >= = ^? N = = ? >== ?? N = ? = = @ ^N > = = ^EGI" = GEC, = > < >= = N > = " 1192 27 ? < 2006, N N ?> ^N < = = >== = > = ^ = N ^N > = ? => < N > ^ = N= =M . ! N >= >=

< P N, < N >= >= ^N < = , N K P = 2006 2010 : > >= N N, = @ > ?>=

!̂ N > > < = = = >= > => N : >= N = < = C < >

8/16/2019 AERES S1 Ecole Centrale Marseille

27/42

1 > : B = > ^N < =

D ? , N? ? >== CCI" (49 E < K ?> >= = 2009, 37 = 20101) >= >= ^N >K = >= N< =N N > ? >? (9,7 E ?? N< = = = 2009 478 _ ?> < = 270 _ ?> > HC = 2010, = = >= N > < = >= >1 461 _ = 2009 K 943 _ = 2010). C = =@ N = , > >

> >= : - 80 _ = ^ ?? = , - 140 _ = >= , - 200 _ = ?!^ == 3 >= = >= ? N N ? N > < > < = ? ^EC" K CCI" N? =

= N ? < >= ?> >= ^N > . C 2010. C ? = = , = = N=N N ? = = = > K ^N > , > > = = = = < = 3,42 "_. A contrario , @ >= ^ <

>= ?> @ > >=, > >= ^EC" K = O < = = = < >= , ^> = >= > = = ? >== > >=

> < = >= N K ^EC" ^N ? < = = N< ^> = >= @ N == > < = = @ >= = ^P = < N ^ =

CCI" => > .

2 & * *#* * < : " * & %" $/ & & /$" & / & < / */

! O< N >= , ?> ^N > , K = = >= > = N < = > N >= ^A -" *= N (A"*) @ , > ? O

10 000 = , >= 4 500 EC. ! 'E , = N = 2007 = > = N , =^ ? ^EC" K ?> @ >= >= ^ = = < = ?N < . !^EC"

^ = : ? < 8 N >?? < = @ ^ = ?> ==N K = , =

?> @ , >= ? = = ? , N > = ?> @ GEC, = N = = . ! N = >= N >= N [ >< N ^>> = N = N < ? = > N = , N N N N >?? < = ? > = ==N .

!^N > > K = = ? = , @ >= ? N ?> > @ ^A"*, = > > = < , >= C#' ^I#

? = >= = >= N N >= > >= (DGG) >= = = ^ = < *"' = , @ ?> >= N@

N > ^N > < ?> N < = = N ? >? . !^= < O , < Q ? > > EC >= > < = Y DGG.

E= < ^ N ?> < = N O , ^EC" = = < = = >= @ N < = N O > K =^ = ? > =>

8/16/2019 AERES S1 Ecole Centrale Marseille

28/42

27

!^ < ?> ^N > ^ ?? > < = = @ ^> GEC, ?> >? = = < = => , N >?? ^ ==> >= < . !^ N >=, = 2

>= >= [C = = \, NN ? N > = ! # = , ? ? ? >= = = O K [C = ==> >=\, N > =N < = = = . C >= >= = K < = = < @ N > CK ^N < = = < ?> @ .

!^ >= ^EC" ?> N >?? ? = = ? > ? < @ N >= ^ = EAD [ O< >

8/16/2019 AERES S1 Ecole Centrale Marseille

29/42

28

!̂ N > < = ? , O N >=, = O< ^ < = >= ?N > @ = N AGA , N >

8/16/2019 AERES S1 Ecole Centrale Marseille

30/42

29

? > >== ? N. E= , ^ = 23

> 154 = N > >==N I N < = @ ^N > ? N >= N , - ^N = N N

N N ? ??> ? < ? N = 77 % = 2008, >= 72 % = 2009 > N N =N = = N N = < O ^ N >= N , - ? = 78 % = 2

I! @ D& %/ *& " * / *" "#/ %& " &$ %& $&

!^N > ?? N K ? ? = , = = >= >= ?N >= : >= ^ == ; = >= N< =N N = = < = , = ?>= > @ < = = = , = = N K > @ . I ?? Q < = @ = =

>= >= ^N < = . ! ? N >== 2011 1,3 "_ G>< 0,7 "_ ?> = JN R< .

!̂ N > > > ^ > N >= = , = >S ^ = < N 13 L < = ? > , ? N = ^ CCI" , @

= JN R< , >S ^N > L < = ? N = = 2 258 = ^ = N < = ?^ = N CN == = ^ = >= = >= ? N ^N > 6 ? < 2007.

? = N N >=, 10 N < 2010, N = K ^ ?> 1 _ < > @ >= = < < . !^ @ = K N N ^ K CCI"

8/16/2019 AERES S1 Ecole Centrale Marseille

31/42

! N< ? == N >= < = , = ? >= = = N?

= = ^ = N CN == , K ? > < N = >= I P = N ? > = < = , = ? = = N N >

= = < = >= ?N N = ? > = ==N ?>

8/16/2019 AERES S1 Ecole Centrale Marseille

32/42

31

!^ ?? = = > ? N > = ^N N< = = = ^N >[C = \ = < = ? N ? N O < N < = ? = = @

^ > >= @ > ? , >= N N < < = = N. I ^ ? >= >= ^N > @ = K > ^ ?? = = > ? = <

C N >= N O , ? N = = = , K ^EC", K < @ > = >= @ = N < @ ? >= = = = < = ( 9O< ? =

< = GEC = 2006 K 20O< ? > ^ ).

C [ ??N = \ ?> ^N > ^ ? < ? >== N >= = = = , ^N > ^ N ^> ^ >= < ? O >

C GE ?> > = < = ? >= > < K < @ C = , = ? ^N > =^ ? = > N > N > ?> = > = N P ?>

D = ? ? , >= >=, ? > N ? = = =>= > ?>= = K N > A >= >= ? @ ?> = ^ = >== = =

? > , ?> >= > ? = ? < = N O , ? N = CA = > N > = ? = ^ >= = ? N > ^ = == ^> 100 _, @ <= >= < = < = >? < N . C > >= >= = N ? >? >=, >= >= = >== ^N > . C = O ^> N [? = \ = ^> ^ =

A - K ^ = N = == , ^EC" N = N >= = K N = N = >=, = > = ? = >= < = N< = = (30 %)

>= < = , > = > = = N = > = < ^ < N [ < U \ ^ >= , = < = > = ? = = , = >= O = ^ = N > => > N N ^N > . C

P ?>= N N = N N ? > < = = ? < K > ^ ?? >? .

L " * " */ %& *%& * < %& < "# * &" " & % & / * * & %& $/ *$" */

8/16/2019 AERES S1 Ecole Centrale Marseille

33/42

32

8/16/2019 AERES S1 Ecole Centrale Marseille

34/42

33

! > ? < = ? > K ? 2003 @ N > ^ = N= " = =^ = = < = ?N N = 2006 [N > C = " \ > ^

N @ > = P = = = @C N >= N N > = < N >= > > ?>=

=@ = .

!^EC" N = 2010 = ? = 220 => N O , = < = K ? >=?N , ?> > ^ >Q K 300 => = = =@ ?

= N ^ < >= ( < = = K ^ = =" 607 N = , ? R - ?

F >= > , = ? >= ? >== < K ?> >=, ? >= = >=, ? >= >= => < N ? O = ?N > = >=. C >= >= = >== N =

@ ?O ?> @ > < = ^N > . E ?> , = 2010, 110

8/16/2019 AERES S1 Ecole Centrale Marseille

35/42

I @ L& /* /

*= >= ^N > ^ = N= N , = N = ? = < = ^EC" = > ? N= > N >= ? ? = = ? > ^N > ;

*= ^ = N= N=N = >=M , > = N ?>*= N = N >= EC ^EC" = = N @ N, ? N

= , @ ? < = > > < = > < >= K ;

D N O = >= = ^N > < N ^ = = >

II @ L& /* "*# &

*= ?> @ > >= = = ;

!^ = > < >= >= = > < >= ? = = ;

! N ^N < = , => = ;

*= = ^> ? > , ? O < = = < O > < = ;

!^ = ?N == N > = CCI" ;

*= >= ? = > @ >= ? = = ?

" = Y = G EC @ ? < = >= >? < = < = >= ?>

C N ?> >== < = ^EC" -K- = N *= N.

34

8/16/2019 AERES S1 Ecole Centrale Marseille

36/42

35

AAC A = > > >= >= N< @C'$* C = N >= Y = >C C>= = @C I C>= ^ = N=

DDGG DN N >= > >=D I D >= O< ^ = > < >=

EEC E= = = EC" > = "EC European credit transfer system ( O< >?N = ^ = N ^ = = < = ?

^ = ? K ^ )ED > > >E# E= >== < = =

8/16/2019 AERES S1 Ecole Centrale Marseille

37/42

FF!E F =M = N = OF' FN N >= F DIE F>= > N N >?? < = = N =

HHC H >

8/16/2019 AERES S1 Ecole Centrale Marseille

38/42

37

O# & " */ % %* &$ &

8/16/2019 AERES S1 Ecole Centrale Marseille

39/42

38

8/16/2019 AERES S1 Ecole Centrale Marseille

40/42

39

8/16/2019 AERES S1 Ecole Centrale Marseille

41/42

40

8/16/2019 AERES S1 Ecole Centrale Marseille

42/42

O (" * " */ %& '< " " */

!^N >= ^ > C = " 17 19 < 2011. ! >< N ^N? N N ? F =M> Peccoud , ? > = N , = = ? N = ^ = N => >

O " *$* < '< " " */ :

B = Baraton , N=N > = , = N " C ;

" Gélin , = == ? N = >= ^ = N= , = == C E ! >= ;

" Géradin , ? > N ;

J =- Lesueur , ? > = N , = N ! < O ! >= 2 ;

= Soulaimani , N N = K ^ = N > .

C Jameux, N N N = @ = = Cosson , N ? > , ? N = = ^AE'E .

!̂ N >= ?> ^N ^N < = < = >S ? >= N N N

D ? =Lecointre N A$.