SUPREME COURT MATTERS - health.delhigovt.nic.in
23
SUPREME COURT MATTERS Sl. Hospital/organ ization name Court name Case no. Case title Name of the Govt. counsel Subject matter of the case (in brief) Status of the case at present Next date of hearing 01 Directorate General of Health Services (DGHS) Supreme Court Suo Moto Writ (Civil) No(s). 1/2015 IN RE:Outrage As Parents End Life After Child's Dengue Death Sh. B.V Balaram Das, Central Agency Initial issue was Dengue /Chikungunya After 11/11/16 Case got connected with 13029/1985 regarding issue of Solid Waste management and matter has been referred to UD Dept. Affidavit filed, Last listed on 02/09/2019 No order of further listing as on 11.11.2019 02 Directorate General of Health Services (DGHS) Supreme Court S.L.P(c) No 29482/2009 Indraprastha Medical Association Vs All India Lawyers Union Sh. B.V Balaram Das Free treatment under Lease condition with IMCL, Affidavit filed, Proceedings continue for response from MoHFW 10 weeks after 02.11.2018 (No order of further listing as on 11.11.2019 03 Directorate General of Health Services (DGHS) Supreme Court WP(C) No. 859/2013 Jaffar Ullah Vs UOI Sh. B.V Balaram Das Health Facilities in Myanmar Refugee camps Affidavit filed, Proceedings continue Last listed on 14.08.2019 No order of further listing as on 11.11.2019 04 Directorate General of Health Services (DGHS) Supreme Court WP(C) No. 760/2014 Vineet Dhanda Vs UOI & Ors Sh. B.V Balaram Das PIL on Spread of Ebola Virus Affidavit filed, (PENDING Final Hearing) No order of further listing as on 11.11.2019
Transcript of SUPREME COURT MATTERS - health.delhigovt.nic.in
SUPREME COURT MATTERS
Sl.
No.
Hospital/organ
ization name
Court
name
Case no. Case title Name of
the
Govt.
counsel
Subject
matter of the
case (in brief)
Status of the
case at present
Next date of
hearing
01
Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS)
Supreme
Court
Suo Moto
Writ (Civil)
No(s).
1/2015
IN
RE:Outrage
As Parents
End Life
After Child's
Dengue
Death
Sh. B.V
Balaram
Das,
Central
Agency
Initial issue
was Dengue
/Chikungunya
After 11/11/16
Case got
connected with
13029/1985
regarding issue
of Solid
Waste
management
and matter has
been referred
to UD Dept.
Affidavit filed,
Last listed
on
02/09/2019
No order of
further
listing as on
11.11.2019
02 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS)
Supreme
Court
S.L.P(c) No
29482/2009
Indraprastha
Medical
Association
Vs All India
Lawyers
Union
Sh. B.V
Balaram
Das
Free treatment
under Lease
condition with
IMCL,
Affidavit filed,
Proceedings
continue for
response from
MoHFW
10 weeks
after
02.11.2018
(No order of
further
listing as on
11.11.2019
03 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS)
Supreme
Court
WP(C) No.
859/2013
Jaffar Ullah
Vs UOI
Sh. B.V
Balaram
Das
Health
Facilities in
Myanmar
Refugee
camps
Affidavit filed,
Proceedings
continue
Last listed
on
14.08.2019
No order of
further
listing as on
11.11.2019
04 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS)
Supreme
Court
WP(C) No.
760/2014
Vineet
Dhanda Vs
UOI & Ors
Sh. B.V
Balaram
Das
PIL on Spread
of Ebola Virus
Affidavit filed,
(PENDING Final
Hearing)
No order of
further
listing as on
11.11.2019
05 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS)
Supreme
Court
W.P(C) No.
50/2015
Arun Dua Vs
UOI & Ors
Sh. B.V
Balaram
Das
PIL for Ban on
Tobacco
Products
Affidavit filed,
Proceedings
continue
06.01.2020
06. Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS)
Supreme
Court
W.P(c) No.
110/2006
Peoples right
and Social
research Vs
UOI & Ors
Sh. B.V
Balaram
Das,
Central
Agency
PIL for
Medical
rehiblitation /
compensation
to Silicosis
victims in Lal
Kuan, ETC
Affidavit filed,
Proceedings
continue
03.12.2019
HIGH COURT MATTERS
Sl.
No.
Hospital/organ
ization name
Court
name
Case no. Case title Name of
the Govt.
counsel
Subject
matter of the
case (in brief)
Status of the
case at present
Next date
of hearing
1 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS)
Delhi
High
Court
W. P(C) No
2554/2012
Rajesh
Chaudhary
Vs GNCTD
& Ors.
Anuj
Agarwal
98913637
18
Writ for
Compensation
and direction
against School
Health
Scheme.
Affidavit filed,
Proceedings
continue
04/12/2019
2 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS)
Delhi
High
Court
W.P(C) No.
5188/14
Sh. Sarvesh
vs AIIMS &
Ors.
5188/14
Prabh
sahay kaur
Financial
assistance to
EWS patients
for treatment
in Govt.
Hospitals
Affidavit filed,
Proceedings
continue
31/01/202
0.
3 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS)
Delhi
High
Court
W.P.(C)
7262/2015
Delhi Anusu
chit Jati Vik
as Sangatha
n (REGD.)
V.
Directorae
Of Health
Services
And Anr
Sanjoy
Ghose
Construction
of Hospital or
in alternative a
Policlinic in
Nangloi area
Affidavit filed,
Petitioner to file
response to the
affidavits filed
by the
Department
DISPOSED
OFF on
01/08/2019
4 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS)
Delhi
High
Court
W.P(c) No.
8917/2015
GAURI
GROVER
Vs.
GOVERNM
ENT OF
NCT OF
DELHI
AND ORS
Sanjoy
Ghose
PIL for
Control
measures
Dengue
/Chikungunya
and Solid
Waste
management
measures
Affidavit filed,
Court,)
27/02/2019
adjourned
sine die
on
27.02.19
( Similar
issue
pending
considerat
ion before
the
Hon’ble
Supreme
Court
5 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS)
Delhi
High
Court
9006/2015 Arpit
Bhargava
vs. GNCT of
Delhi
Thorugh Its
Chief
Secretary
And Ors
Sanjoy
Ghose
PIL for
Control
measures
Dengue
/Chikungunya
and Solid
Waste
management
measures
Affidavit filed,
Proceedings
continue
adjourned
sine die on
27.02.19
( Similar
issue
pending
considerati
on before
the
Hon’ble
Supreme
Court
6 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS)
Delhi
High
Court
W.P.(C) 82
18/2017
ASSOCIAT
ION OF
PRACTISIN
G
PATHOLO
GISTS
(REGD.)
Vs. GNCT
OF DELHI
Ramesh
Singh
Ceiling of
Rates on
Dengue
Chikungunya
Test
Affidavit filed,
Proceedings
continue
REGULAR
on 27/08/2018
7 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS)
Delhi
High
Court
W. P(C) No
6093/12
Sh. R.S
Yadav Vs
GNCTD &
Ors.
Sachin
Nahar
99531689
69
Medical
reimbursement
Claim of a
Pensioner
under DGEHS
Affidavit filed,
Proceedings
continue
21/11/2019
8 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS)
Delhi
High
Court
W. P(C) No
553/14
Samudayik
kalindi
alian samiti
AnrVs
South Delhi
Municipal C
oroporation
& ors.
Prabh
Sahay
Kaur
Registration of
Nurshin Home
and
compliance of
MPD 2021
Affidavit filed,
Proceedings
continue
25.03.2020
9 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS)
Delhi
High
Court
cont.case(c)
no.829/13
GNCTD Vs
Dr.Pramod
Gautam &
Others.
Naushad
Ahmad
Khan
Free treatment
to EWS patient
in private
Hospital
Proceedings
continue
29/01/2020
10 Directorate
General of
Health Services
Delhi
High
W.P.(C) 77
44/2017
PARMESH
WARI
DEVI Vs.
Manika
Tripathy
PIL for Health
Facilities,
Parking Toilet
Affidavit Filed
DISPOSED
OFF on
(DGHS) Court UNION OF
INDIA
AND ORS
Pandy facilities in
Nangloi area
13/08/2019
11 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS)
Delhi
High
Court
W.P(C) No.
5632/2015
Meena
Srivastava
vs. DHS
(Govt. Of
nct of delhi
Sanjoy
Ghose,
Medical
Negligence/
ICU facilities
in a Nursing
Home
registered
under DNHR
Act
Reply and
Written
Submission filed.
Proceedings to
continue
07/01/2020
12 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS)
Delhi
High
Court
W.P.(C) No.
6538/15
Rukhsana
Vs Rajiv
Gandhi
cancer
Institute
and
Research
Center
Swati
Singh
Mallik
Free treatment
to EWS patient
in private
Rajeev Gandhi
CancerInstitute
& Reseach
Center
Affidavit and
written
Submission filed
Proceedings
continue
Disposed off
on
15/10/2019
13 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS)
Delhi
High
Court
Crl. Rev. P.
317/2015
Shalu
Singhal
Vs DHS
APP Registration of
Nursing Home
Affidavit filed,
Reply to
application for
stay to be filed
23/01/2020
14 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS)
Delhi
High
Court
W.P(c) No.
5228/2015
Flt. Lt.
Rajan Dhall
Charitable
Hospital Vs
Prabhat
Kumar &
Ors
Satyakam Disclosure of
information
from
registered
Nursing Home
Comments
Provided
Affidavit yet to
be filed
04.02.2020
15 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS)
Delhi
High
Court
W.P.(C)
2932/2014
TDI FUN
REPUBLIC
SHOP
OWNER
Vs. LT.
GOVERNO
R AND
ORS
Sanjoy
Ghose
Public Health
w.r.t mobile
tower
Proceedings
continue for
Final Disposal
25/11/2019
16 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS)
Delhi
High
Court
W.P(c) No.
7852/2016
Pushpawati
Singhania
Research
Institute Vs
GNCTD
Gautam
Narayan
Recovery
against Unjust
Enrichment
Affidavit filed
Proceedings
continue
21/11/2019
17 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS)
Delhi
High
Court
W.P(c) No.
7082/2016
Meena Devi
Vs AIIMS
and Ors
Gautam
Narayan
Free
Treatment and
Health
Facilities In
Govt.
Hospitals to
EWS patients
Affidavit filed
Proceedings
continue
Disposed off
on 14/10/2019
18 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS)
Delhi
High
Court
W.P(c) No.
8213/2016
Thiruvara
Hansa
Pandey Vs
UOI & Ors
Mrinalini
Sen
Free
Treatment
Affidavit yet to
be filed
20.01.2020
19 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS)
Delhi
High
Court
CS(Comm)
5/2017
Sanjeev
Arora Vs
Chief
Secretary &
Ors
P.S Kaur Claim of
Payment for
vehicles
suppied under
to Mobile
Health Scheme
Affidavits Filed
Proceedings
continue
16.10.2019
.
20 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS)
Delhi
High
Court
W.P(c)
4349/17
COURT
ON ITS
OWN
MOTION
Vs. GOVT
OF NCT
OF DELHI
& ORS.
Nidhi
Raman
Medical
Facility to
Cancer
patients in
Shiv Vihar
area
Affidavit filed
Proceedings
continue
DISPOSED
OFF on
05/08/2019
21 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS)
Delhi
High
Court
W.P.(C)
4552/2016
SANJAY
TIWARI
Vs.
GOVT. OF
NCT OF
DELHI &
ORS
Satyakam PIL for Policy
on Autistic
patient care in
Pvt / Govt.
Hospitals
Affidavit filed
Proceedings
continue
Disposed off
on
18/10/2019
22 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS)
Delhi
High
Court
W.P(c) No.
7811/17
Delhi
Network Of
Positive
People and
Anr Vs
GNCTD and
Ors
Satyakam PIL for Policy/
free Health
facilities to
Hepatic HIV
patients
Affidavit Filed
by DGHS and
matter referred to
Nodal officer,
DSHM
DISPOSED
OFF on
23/08/2019
23 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS)
Delhi
High
Court
W.P(c) N0.
5999/2016
PC GARG
VS UOI &
ORS
Sanjay
Dewan
Challenging
CGEHS/DGE
HS /Ceiling
rates
notification
Affidavit filed
Proceedings
continue
Disposed off
on
30/09/2019
24 Directorate
General of
Delhi
High
W.P.(C) DOCTORS
FOR YOU
Sanjoy Implemention
of COTPA
Affidavit filed
Proceedings
Health Services
(DGHS)
Court 8849/2017 Vs. THE
GOVERNM
ENT OF
NCT OF
DELHI &
ORS
Ghose Rules / Anti
Tobacco
Policy against
E Cigarettes
and E vapour
products
continue DISPOSED
OFF on
14/08/2019
25 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS)
Delhi
High
Court
WP(C)
11610/2017
FSMA
Charitable
Trust Vs
UOI & Ors
Devesh
Singh
Policy on Free
Treatment to
EWS patient
sof Rare
disease
Affidavit filed
Proceedings
continue
12/12/2019
26 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS)
Delhi
High
Court
WP(C)
8156/2017
Justice for
all Vs
GNCTD &
Ors
Sanjoy
Ghosh
PIL for
Opening of
AAMC and
NOC/Land
requirement
Proceedings
continue
20/01/2020
27 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS)
Delhi
High
Court
WP(C)
957/2018
Anil Dutt
Sharma Vs
GNCTD &
Ors
Anupam
Shrivastav
/ Dhairya
Guopa
Health
standard in
govt hospital
and price
caping in pvt
hospalst
Affidavit filed
Proceedings
continue
DISPOSED
OFF on
02/09/2019
28 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS)
Delhi
High
Court
WP(C)
2271/2015
Raj Kumar
Kaushik Vs
Gnctd
Anuj Agg Encroachment
of hospital
land
Affidavit filed
Proceedings
continue
24/03/2020
29 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS)
Delhi
High
Court
W.P.(C)
10919/2017
VEENA
versus
DEPARTM
ENT OF
HEALTH
AND
FAMILY
WELFARE
AND
ORS
Satyakam Heath Facility
in Kathputli
Colony
Proceedings
continue
Disposed off
on
04/07/2019
30 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS)
Delhi
High
Court
RFA No.
160/09
GNCTD Vs
& Naresh &
Ors.
Ramesh
Singh
Equal pay for
Equal work
Affidavit filed,
Proceedings
continue
REGULAR
on
24/02/2010
31 Directorate
General of
Health Services
Delhi
High
Court
W. P(C) No.
3520/94
Sant baba
Gurmail
singh Vs
UOI & Ors.
Santosh
Tripathi
Construction
of Hospital
Affidavit filed,
Proceedings
continue
REGULAR
on
(DGHS) 114/94 &
3520/94
21/01/2019
32 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS)
Delhi
High
Court
W. P(C) No.
114/94
Sant baba
Gurmail
singh Vs
UOI & Ors.
114/94 &
3520/94
Santosh
Tripathi
Enchrochment
on private land
in
Construction
of Hospital
Affidavit filed,
Proceedings
continue
REGULAR
ons
21/01/2019
33 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS)
Delhi
High
Court
W. P(C) No.
9408/09
Smt. Raj
Bala Vs
GNCTD,
9408/09
Meera
Bhatiya
Appointment
of ANM Staff
Affidavit filed,
Proceedings
continue
REGULAR
on
02/03/2016
34 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS)
Delhi
High
Court
W. P(C) No.
8001/04
Banwari lal
Charitable
trust & Ors.
Vs
UOI,8001/2
004
Naushad
Ahmad
Khan
Registration of
Nursing Home
Affidavit filed,
Proceedings
continue
REGULAR
on
02/07/2018
35 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS)
Delhi
High
Court
W.P.(C)
2129/2018
Chatter
Singh
Rachayya &
Anr Vs
GNCTD &
Ors.
Anupam
Shrivastva
Construction
of Hospital in
burari
Reply filed
Proceedings
continue
16/12/2019
36 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS)
Delhi
High
Court
W.P.(C)
8994/2017
Madhu Bala
Vs GNCTD
& Ors.
Sanjoy
Ghosh
Management
of Health
Facilities in
Govt. hospitals
Reply filed
Proceedings
continue
05/12/201
9
37 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS)
Delhi
High
Court
W.P. (C)
10624/17
Seema
Sehgal Vs
Union of
India & Ors.
Sanjoy
Ghosh
Regulatory
measures/
Facilities in
AAMC
ATR filed
Proceedings
continue
25/11/2019
38 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS)
Delhi
High
Court
W.P©
83/2018
NIDHI
GUPTA Vs
GOVT. OF
NCT OF
DELHI
AND ANR
Sanjoy
Ghose
PIL to enact
Clinical
establishment
Act
ATR filed
Proceedings
personal
appearance of PS
health on
18/12/2019
39 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS)
Delhi
High
Court
WP(C)
9283/2018
Bijon Kuma
r Mishra Vs
GNCTD &
Anr
GAUTA
M
NARAYA
N
PIL to enact
Clinical
establishment
Act
ATR filed
Proceedings
personal
appearance of PS
health on
18/12/2019
40 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS
Delhi
High
Court
WP(C)
11902/2018
Sangeeta
Banerjee Vs
GNCTD
Sanjoy
Ghose
PIL to enact
Clinical
establishment
Act
ATR filed
Proceedings
personal
appearance of PS
health on
18/12/2019
41 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS)
Delhi
High
Court
WP(C)
6320/2018
ESCORTS
HEART
INST. Vs
DGHS
Ramesh
singh
Recovery
against unjust
enrichment as
per directions
of Hon'ble
High Court of
Delhi in
‘Social Jurist”
Reply filed 16/12/2019
s
42 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS
Delhi
High
Court
WP(C)
8798/2018
Court on its
own motion
Vs UOI &
Ors
Anjum
Javed
Provision of
Defibrillator
facility for
public
Reply yet to be
filed
20/11/2019
43 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS
Delhi
High
Court
WP(C)
10456/2018
Indian
Spinal
Injury
Centre Vs
GNCTD
Sanjoy
Ghose
Nursing Home Affidavit filed 02/12/2019
44 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS
Delhi
High
Court
WP(C)
9591/2018
Kavya
Sehgal Vs
UOI & Ors
Anuj
Agarwal
Free treatment
to EWS patient
suffering Rare
disease
Status report to
be filed
DISPOSED OFF
on11/09/2019
45 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS
Delhi
High
Court
WP(C)
644/2017
Jagvir Singh
Vs DMC
P. s. Kaur Regulation of
Anti Qackery
against
Homeopathy/
Homeoelectro
pathy
treatment
Reply filed Next Date:
28/11/2019
46 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS
Delhi
High
Court
WP(C)
11485/2018
Social jurist.
A civil
reghts group
Vs Rajiv
Gandhi
Cancer
Institute
And
Research
Centre And
Ors
G
Narayan
Free
Treatment in
RGCRI as per
directions of
Hon'ble High
Court of Delhi
in ‘Social
Jurist”
Reply yet to be
filed
Disposed off
on
15/10/2019
47 Directorate
General of
Delhi
High
W.P© No. K.D. Sanjoy Starting
/Running of
Disposed off on Disposed
Health Services
(DGHS
Court 579/2018 INSHA
Vs.
PRINCIPAL
SECRETAR
Y, GOVT.
OF NCT OF
DELHI &
ORS
Ghose Polyclinic in
govindpuri
19.07.2019 off
48 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS
Delhi
High
Court
W.P© No.
/2019
SMS Water
Grace (Pvt.
Ltd. BMW)
Vs GNCTD
Anuj
Aggarwal
Appointment
of arbitrator
Matter referred
to arbitration by
High Court.
Disposed
off on
03/09/2019
49 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS
Delhi
High
Court
W.P© No.
5284/2018
XYZ Vs
GNCTD
Hitu
Arora
Sethi
Medical
Negligence
Status filed 28/11/2019
50 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS
Delhi
High
Court
W.P© No.
12146/2018
Justice for
all Vs
GNCTD
Santosh
Kr
Tripathi
Nizul Land
EWS case
Filed 06.12.2019
51
52 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS
Delhi
High
Court
W.P© No.
7291/2018
Association
of Health
Care
Provider
(India)
Vs GNCTD
Sanjoy
Ghose
Starting
/Running of
Polyclinic in
govindpuri
Status filed JUDGMENT
RESERVED
on 28/09/2018
53 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS
Delhi
High
Court
WP(C)
6684/2018
DHARAMS
HILA
HOSPITAL
AND
RESEARC
H CENTRE
(THR ITS
PRESIDEN
T –
Ramesh
Singh
Recovery
against unjust
enrichment as
per directions
of Hon'ble
High Court of
Delhi in
‘Social Jurist”
Affidavit filed 21/11/2019
54 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS
Delhi
High
Court
W.P.(C)
6932/2018
DEVKI
DEVI
FOUNDATI
ON Vs
DIRECTOR
ATE
GENERAL
OF
HEALTH
Dhananja
ya Mishra
Recovery
against unjust
enrichment as
per directions
of Hon'ble
High Court of
Delhi in
‘Social Jurist”
Affidavit filed 21/11/2019
SERVICES
& ANR
55 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS
Delhi
High
Court
WP(C)8548/
2017
COURT ON
ITS OWN
MOTION
Vs. UNION
OF INDIA
AND ORS
Satyakam ICU/Ventilator
beds
availability in
Govt/Pvt
Hospitals
Status report
filed
further ATR is to
be filed
27/11/2019
56 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS
Delhi
High
Court
WP(C)
5377/2019
SHANTI
MUKAND
HOSPITAL
Vs. THE
SECRETAR
Y (HEALTH)
DEPT. OF
HEALTH
GOVERNME
N
PS
Kaur/Ram
esh Singh
Recovery wrt
Free
Treatment in
Pvt. Identified
Hospital
Comments sent
Status yet to be
filed
21/11/2019
58 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS
Delhi
High
Court
WP(C)
12315/2018
Hari Prakash
Vs GNCTD
Yeshu
Jain
Service matter
CDMO NW
Dist reg. SCC
staff
Comments sent
Status yet to be
filed
26/02/2020
59 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS
Delhi
High
Court
WPC
2727/2019
Rahul Mohod
vs UOI & Ors
Anjum
Javed
Rabbies
Vaccine
Disposed off
13/08/2019
DISPOSED
OFF on
13/08/2019
60 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS
Delhi
High
Court
W.P.(C)
7079/2019
ABHIJIT
MISHRA
Vs
GNCTD
Sanjoy
Ghose
DHCL &
DAK funding
to DHCL
Disposed off on
17/09/2019
Dismissed
on
17/09/2019
61 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS
Delhi
High
Court
FAO
629/2019
Directorate
General Of
Health
Services
Vs Ms
Bansal
General
Store
Pravesh
Thakur
Appeal agains
CS decree
Appeal against
money decree
13/01/2020
62 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS
Delhi
High
Court
W.P.(C)
2468/2019
Legal
forum for
women
empowerm
ent vs.
Goverment
of nct of
Delhi
Sanjoy
Ghose
Price capping
in private
hospital
services
Filed Disposed
off
23/10/2019
63 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS
Delhi
High
Court
W.P.(C)
6995/2019
ABHIJIT
MISHRA
Vs.
GOVERNME
NT OF NCT
OF DELHI &
ANR
Sanjoy
Ghose
DAK only for
GNCTD
resident, why
not outsiders
Comments sent
Status yet to be
filed
20/11/2019
64 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS
Delhi
High
Court
W.P.(C)
1843/2019
Dr. Rohit Jain
Vs UOI &
Ors
Sanjoy
Ghose
Regulation of
Pvt Labs
Comments sent
Status yet to be
filed
10/12/2019
65 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS
Delhi
High
Court
WP(C) No
8851/2019
Swati
Gupta Vs
UOI and
ORS
Avnish
Ahlawat
Service matter Comments sent
Status yet to be
filed
14.01.202
0
66 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS
Delhi
High
Court
WP (C)
9579/18
K D
INSHA Vs
UOI &
ORS
ANUJ
AGGAR
WAL
RARE
DISESSE
Disposed off on
admission stage
DISPOSED
OFF ON
11/7/19
67 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS
Delhi
High
Court
WP (C)
2513/19
COURT
OF ITS
OWN
MOTION
VS UOI &
ORS
ANUPA
M
SHRIVAS
TAV
HOSPITAL
CSR/CHARIT
ABLE ACC
Affidavit yet to
be filed
DISPOSED
OFF ON
15/7/19
68 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS
Delhi
High
Court
WP (C)
10277/2019
Sanatan
Dharam
Sabha Hari
Mandir
Regd. &
Anr Vs O/o
CDMO
Central
Distt.
Sanjoy
Ghosh
AAMC Health facilities Disposed off
on
23/09/2019s
69 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS
Delhi
High
Court
WP(C) No
8104/2018
All India
Association
of PHD
Doctors,
Scientists
&
Consultant
in Medical
Science Vs
Hetu
Arora
Sethi
Clinical
establishment
Act
Regulation of Pvt
Nursing Homes
26/11/2019
UOI & Ors
70 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS
Delhi
High
Court
WP (C)
3278/19
Association
of
practicing
pathologist
Vs UOI &
Anr
Sanjoy
Ghosh
Clinical
establishment
Act
Status yet to be
filed
26/11/2019
71 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS
Delhi
High
Court
W.P.(C)
10007/2019
K.R.Chitra
Vs UOI &
Ors
Sanjoy
Ghose
Regulation on
Pvt.
Laboratories
Comments sent
Affidavit to be filed
14.01.2020
72 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS
Delhi
High
Court
W.P.(C)
/2019
ABHIJIT
MISHRA
Vs.
GOVERNME
NT OF NCT
OF DELHI &
ANR
Sanjoy
Ghose
Contractual
employee
EPF/Labour
law, payment
delay, bonus
etc
Comments yet to
be sent
19/11/2019
73 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS
Delhi
High
Court
W.P.(C)
/2019
Ravi Gupta
alias Ravi
Prakash Vs
DHS & Delhi
Admn
Siraspur
Hospital
Project
No order of
Affidavit Yet
09/12/2019
74 Directorate
General of
Health Services
(DGHS
Delhi
High
Court
W.P.(C)
/2019
PRATYUSH
KANTH
AND ANR
vs THE
GOVT. OF
NCT OF
DELHI AND
ORS.
Sanjoy
Ghose
Pmjay
ayushman
bharat to be
implemented
in NCT
Status yet to be
filed
04/11/2019
C.A.T. MATTERS
Sl.
No.
Hospital/organ
ization name
Court
name
Case no. Case title Name of the
Govt.
counsel
Subject matter
of the case (in
brief)
Status of
the case
at
present
Next date of
hearing
1 Directorate of
Health
Services (
School Health
Scheme,DHS,
(HQ))
C.A.T. OA No
1148/2015
Neerja
SoodVs
GNCTD
V.K.
Pandita
MACP
benefits
C.A.
filed
10.12.2019
2 Directorate of
Health
Services (
AO-
Vigilance)
C.A.T. OA No
4025/2015
DS Rao Vs
GNCTD
Avnish
Ahlawat
Subsitence
Allowance
C.A.
filed
07.11.2019
3 Directorate of
Health
Services (
CDMO-N)
C.A.T. OA No
3061/2015
Jitender
Kumar Vs
GNCTD
V.K.
Pandita
Recovery &
Pay parity of
contractual
para medical
staff
C.A.
filed
06.11.2019
(dismissed as
withdrawn)
4 Directorate of
Health
Services (AO-
Vigilance)
C.A.T. OA No
1469/2017
Vandana
Kohli Vs
GNCTD
V.K.
Pandita
Seeking
higher Pay
Band
C.A.
filed
16.01.2020
5 Directorate of
Health
Services
C.A.T OA No
3484/2016
Anju Bala
Vs GNCTD
Amit Anand Contractual
Pharmacist
since 1999
seeking
Regularisation
C.A.
filed
28.11.2019
6 Directorate of
Health
Services
C.A.T OA No
1992/2017
Sunita Vs
GNCTD
Amit Anand Contractual
Pharmacist
since 1999
seeking
Regularisation
C.A.
filed
19.11.2019
7 Directorate of
Health
Services
C.A.T OA No
2568/2017
Ram
Chander
Yadav Vs
GNCTD
Amit Anand Appointment C.A.
filed
02.12.2019
8 Directorate of
Health
Services
C.A.T OA No
2789/2017
Mamta &
Ors Vs
GNCTD
Amit Anand Daily wages
Workers
outsourced
,seeking
regularisation
C.A.
filed
17.12.2019
9 Directorate of
Health
Services
C.A.T OA No
2808/2017
with
Contempt
Petition No.
645/2017
Sushil
Kumar &
ors Vs
GNCTD
Amit Anand Daily wages
Workers
outsourced
,seeking
regularisation
C.A.
filed
20.11.2019
10 Directorate of
Health
Services
C.A.T OA No
2866/2017
Rama Devi
Vs GNCTD
Amit Anand Daily wages
Workers
outsourced
,seeking
regularisation
C.A.
filed
09.12.2019
11 Directorate of
Health
Services
C.A.T OA No.
3792/2017
Jitender
Kumar Vs
GNCTD
Amit Anand Daily wages
Workers
outsourced
,seeking
regularisation
Reply
Filed
09.12.2019
12 Directorate of
Health
Services
C.A.T OA No.
4134/2017
Renu
Chauhan Vs
GNCTD
Amit Anand Daily wages
Workers
outsourced
,seeking
regularisation
Reply
Filed
17.12.2019
13 Directorate of
Health
Services
C.A.T OA No.
939/2018
with
Contempt
Petition No.
445/2018
Shantu
Mondal Vs
GNCTD
Amit Anand Daily wages
Workers
outsourced
,seeking
regularisation
Reply
Filed
09.12.2019
14 Directorate of
Health
Services
C.A.T Contempt
Case 435/18
Shrikant
Behra Vs
GNCTD
Amit Anand Seeking OPS Reply
filed
25.11.2019
15 Directorate of
Health
Services
C.A.T OA No.
3284/18
Manoj
Kumar
Palival Vs
GNCTD
Harvinder
Oberoi
Daily wages
Workers
outsourced
,seeking
regularisation
Reply
filed
20.11.2019
16 Directorate of
Health
Services
C.A.T OA NO.
3298/18
Mukesh
Kumar Vs
GNCTD
Harvinder
Oberoi
Daily wages
Workers
outsourced
,seeking
regularisation
Reply
filed
20.11.2019
17 Directorate of
Health
Services
C.A.T OA No.
3396/2018
Raj Kumar
Vs GNCTD
Amit Anand Daily wages
Workers
outsourced
,seeking
regularisation
Reply
filed
17.12.2019
18 Directorate of
Health
Services
C.A.T OA No.
3461/2018
Ravi
KumarVs
GNCTD
Harvinder
Oberoi
Daily wages
Workers
outsourced
,seeking
regularisation
Reply
filed
30.10.2019
19 Directorate of
Health
Services
C.A.T OA No.
3855/2018
Kavindra Vs
GNCTD
Harvinder
Oberoi
Daily wages
Workers
outsourced
,seeking
regularisation
Reply
filed
17.12.2019
20 Directorate of
Health
Services
C.A.T OA No.
3170/2018
Naveen Puri
Vs GNCTD
Harvinder
Oberoi
Daily wages
Workers
outsourced
,seeking
regularisation
Reply
filed
10.12.2019
21 Directorate of
Health
Services
C.A.T OA No
623/2019
Kuldeep
Ors Vs
GNCTD
Anuj
Sharma
Daily wages
Workers
outsourced
,seeking
regularisation
Reply
filed
06.11.2019
22 Directorate of
Health
Services
C.A.T OA No
23/2019
Kulwant Vs
GNCTD
Kapil
Agnihotri
Pharmacist
posted as
Caretaker
seeking
caretaking
allowance
To be
filed
14.11.2019
23 Directorate of
Health
Services
C.A.T OA No
694/2019
Indar & Ors
Vs GNCTD
Anuj
Sharma
Daily wages
Workers
outsourced
,seeking
regularisation
Reply
filed
20.11.2019
24 Directorate of
Health
Services
C.A.T OA No
2335/2018
Arun & Ors
Vs GNCTD
Amit Anand Daily wages
Workers
outsourced
,seeking
regularisation
Reply
filed
17.12.2019
25 Directorate of
Health
Services
C.A.T OA No
4317/2018
Rahul &
Ors Vs
GNCTD
Anuj
Sharma
Daily wages
Workers
outsourced
,seeking
regularisation
Reply
filed
20.11.2019
26 Directorate of
Health
Services
C.A.T OA No
4408/2018
Naresh &
Ors Vs
GNCTD
Amit Anand Daily wages
Workers
outsourced
,seeking
regularisation
Reply
filed
17.12.2019
27 Directorate of
Health
Services
C.A.T OA No
895/2019
Gursharan
Singh Vs
GNCTD
Amit Anand Revised
Pension
To be
filed
03.12.2019
28 Directorate of
Health
Services
C.A.T OA No
1759/2019
Suresh
kumar Vs
GNCTD
Anuj Kr
Sharma
Daily wages
Workers
outsourced
,seeking
regularisation
Pension
Reply
filed
13.11.2019
29 Directorate of
Health
Services
C.A.T OA No
1424/17
Santosh
Kumar
Arora Vs
GNCTD
Saurabh
Chadda
Reimburseme
nt(DGEHS)
filed 18.11.2019
30 Directorate of
Health
Services
C.A.T MA No
1511/19
Subhash
Chand Vs
GNCTD
Anuj Kr
Sharma
Pay parity To be
filed
06.12.2019
31 Directorate of
Health
Services
C.A.T OA No
2380/19
Prem Sagar
Vs GNCTD
Amit Anand Dismissal/
Termination
To be
filed
13.01.2020
32 Directorate of
Health
Services
C.A.T CP No 430 in
OA No
1108/2019
Tejinder pal
singh &
others
-v/s-
Vijay kumar
dev & ors
Amit Anand Non
Compliance of
directiobns of
CAT to pass a
speaking order
for grant of
equal pay for
To be
filed
03.12.2019
DISTRICT COURT MATTERS
equal work at
par with
regular
employees
33 Directorate of
Health
Services
C.A.T CP No 431 in
OA No
1137/2019
Renu &
others
-v/s-
Vijay kumar
dev & ors
Amit Anand Non
Compliance of
directiobns of
CAT to pass a
speaking order
for grant of
equal pay for
equal work at
par with
regular
employees
To be
filed
03.12.2019
34 Directorate of
Health
Services
C.A.T CP No 432 in
OA No
1086/2019
Neetu Pal &
others
-v/s-
Vijay kumar
dev & ors
Amit Anand Non
Compliance of
directiobns of
CAT to pass a
speaking order
for grant of
equal pay for
equal work at
par with
regular
employees
To be
filed
03.12.2019
Sl.
No.
Hospital/organiz
ation name
Court
name
Case
no.
Case title Name of
the Govt.
counsel
Subject
matter of
the case
(in brief)
Status of the
case at
present
Next date of
hearing
1 Directorate of
Health Services
( CMO ( Public
Grievance Cell))
Tishazari 152/1
0
Smt Azeema
Khatoon Vs
Hindu Rao
Hospital &
Smt.
Bindiya
Savara
Medical
Negligenc
e
Final
Argument
26.11.2019
Ors.
2
Directorate of
Health Services
( Nursing home
cell)
Tishazari 98321
/15
Abdul Jabbar
Vs Noorulla
Masoom &
Ors.
Ms Arpita
Mandal
Running
Hospital
Without
Registrati
on
Order on
misc.
application
04.02.2020
3
Directorate of
Health Services
(Mobile Health
)SHS
Tishazari 313/1
5
M/s Mukesh
Bansal Vs
DHS or M/s
Smat Firms Vs
DHS
Ms Babli
Kala
Payment
Against
Supply
Case Re-
opened with
new name
07.12.2019
4
Directorate of
Health Services
( Nursing home
cell)
Rause
Avenue
355/2
016
Indu Mahajan
& Ors. Vs The
Secretary,
Ministry of
Finance
Smt.
Bindiya
Savara
Services
matter for
implemen
tation of
6th pay
commissi
on report.
Defendant
evidence
15.01.2019
5
Directorate of
Health Services
(Nursing Home
Cell,
DHS/DGEHS
Branch )
Karkardo
oma
832/1
4
Dinesh Pratap
Singh Vs DHS
Sh
Pratysh
Gupta
Medical
Negligenc
e
Petitioners
Evidence
16.12.2019
7
Directorate of
Health Services
(CDMO (North
West District )
Rause
Avenue
546,54
7,548,
549,55
0,551,
553,55
4,567,
564,/2
014
Sh. Prakash &
9 Ors. Vs
CDMO (NW)
GNCTD
Smt.
Bindiya
Savara
Services
Matter for
regularisa
tion
Petitioners
Evidence
03.02.2020
05.02.2020
10.02.2020
19.02.2020
8 Directorate of
Health Services
( Nursing home
cell)
Karkardo
oma
53341
/2016
DHS Vs Shalu
Singhal
Sh Rahul
Sharma
Complain
t Lodge
by DHS
Argument on
charge
28-11-2020
9
Directorate of
Health Services (
Administrative
Rohini
Court
423/1
4
Ishwer Singh
Vs CMO
Rajan Babu
T.B. Hospital
Sh. Ashok
Popli
Medical
Negligenc
e
Final
Arguments
24.01.2020
branch) & Ors.
10
Directorate of
Health Services
(Nursing Home
cell )
Rohini
Court
38254
/10
DHS Vs Balaji
Hospital
Smt.
Bindiya
Savara
Running
Hospital
Without
Registrati
on
Order Order
reserved
11 Directorate of
Health Services (
Anti Qucks Cell)
Rohini
Court
314/1
4
Dr. Arun Roy
Vs DMC
Smt.
Bindiya
Savara
Medical
Negligenc
e
Petitioners
Evidence
27.11.2019
12
Directorate of
Health Services (
DGEHS Cell)
Janakpuri 388/1
5
Dharmpal
Gupta Vs DHS
Smt.
Bindiya
Savara
Medical
Claim
Proceedings
continue
20.02.20
13 Directorate of
Health Services (
Nursing Home
Cell,)
Shalimar
Bagh
1027/
2011
Smt Usha devi
Vs Ministry of
Health and
Ors.
Smt.
Bindiya
Savara
Medical
Negligenc
e
Arguments 02.12.2019
14 Directorate of
Health Services (
DGEHS Cell,)
Shalimar
Bagh
416/2
013
Sh. Satish
Kumar Chadha
Amit
Dhankhar
Medical
Claim
Arguments 17-02-2020
15
Directorate of
Health Services
(DGEHS Cell, )
Shalimar
Bagh
104/2
013
Sh. Satya
Narayan Vs
Dr. P.K. Malik
A.D.
(DGEHS)
Smt.
Bindiya
Savara
Medical
Claim
Proceedings
continue
(documents
to be
submitted by
plaintiff)
03-02-2020
16 Directorate of
Health Services
(DGEHS Cell, )
Sani
Enclave
650/1
4
Raj Bala Vs
DHS
Smt.
Bindiya
Savara
Medical
claim
Proceedings
continue
Order
Reserved
17
Directorate of
Health Services
(DGEHS Cell, )
Saini
Enclave
CC
No.
67/16
Umrao Singh
Vs DGEHS &
Anr.
Sh
Pratysh
Gupta
Medical
Claim
Defendant
Evidence
20.02.20
18 Directorate of
Health Services
Publice Health
Wing,DHS
Tis Hazari
Court
CS/SC
J/2914
/2017
Ved Prakash
Jain Vs
GNCTD &
Ors.
Sh
Abhiman
u Garg
Payments
against
supply
Proceedings
continue
17.11.2019
19 Directorate of
Finance CS Max Smt. De- Affidavit Filed 15.11.2019
Health Services Commissi
oner
No.
335/1
7
Healthcare
Pvt. Ltd. Vs
DGHS
Bindiya
Savara
registratio
n of
Nursing
Home
20
Directorate of
Health Services
Saket
Court
RCA/
120/2
017
Smt Vimla
Singh Vs All
India Blind
Relief Society
Ms Arun
Kumar
Services
Matter
Arguments 16.11.2019
21 Directorate of
Health Services
Tis Hazari
Court
CS
No.
1070/
18
Vishnu Pouch
Packaging Pvt
Ltd Vs DGHS
Ashok
Popli
Surrogate
Advertise
ment
Final
Arguments
08.07.2020
22 Directorate of
Health Services
Tis Hazari
Court
Som Pan
Product Pvt
Ltd Vs DGHS
Ashok
Popli
Surrogate
Advertise
ment
Final
Arguments
08.07.2020
23 Directorate of
Health Services
Karkardo
oma
Court
DGHS Vs
Rahim Baksh
Pratyaksh
Gupta
Running
Hospital
Without
Registrati
on
Proceedings
continue
21.01.2020
24 Directorate of
Health Services
Rause
Avenue
Courts
LIR
1325/
18
Promila & 39
Ors Vs DHS
Shyam
Sunder
Services
Matter
For issues 20-02-2020
25 Directorate of
Health Services
Saket
Court
CS
No.
551/1
8
Dr. Sunil
Dangwal Vs
DMC & Ors.
Sh Arun
Kumar
Anti
Quackery
W/S filed 04-12-2019
26 Directorate of
Health Services
Finance
Commissi
oner
CS no
339/1
8
Welcome
Medical
Centre Vs
DGHS
Pratyaksh
Gupta
De-
registration
of Nursing
Home
Arguments 07.01.2020
27 Directorate of
Health Services
Karkardo
oma
Court
CS No.
590/18
R.L Gupta Vs
MS Max Super
Speciality
HospitalOrs.
Satender
Kumar
Medical
Negligence
WS filed 23.11.2019
28 Directorate of
Health Services
Rause
Avenue
Courts
240/2
018
Suresh Kumari
Vs DHS
Shyam
Sunder
Services
Matter
For W/S 19/11/2019
29
Directorate of
Health Services
Rause
Avenue
Courts
POIT/
301/2
018
Savita Rani
VS DHS
Shyam
Sunder
Services
Matter
For W/S 12.12.2019
30 Directorate of
Health Services
Patiala
House
Cs227
3/19
DGHS VS
J.N.Yadav
Sh Pranav
Jain
Running
Hospital
Without
Registrati
on
Misc.
arguments
11.03.2020
31 Directorate of
Health Services
Dwarka
Courts
Cs
1222/
18
Chanarik
Prasad Singh
Vs UOI&Ors
Sh Shyam
Sunder
Dalal
Running
Hospital
Without
Registrati
on
Affidavit yet
to be filed
02.12.2019
32 Directorate of
Health Services
Finance
Commissi
oner
case
no.471
/18
Jyoti Clinic &
Nursing Home
Vs DGHS
Smt.
Bindiya
Savara
De-
registratio
n of
Nursing
Home
For filing of
WS
05.12.2019
33 Directorate of
Health Services
Karkardo
oma
Court
ct
599/2
019
Care New
Born &Child
Hospital
Sh
Satender
Kumar
Running
Hospital
Without
Registrati
on
Misc.
arguments
19.11.2019
34
Directorate of
Health Services
Rohini
Court
CS/19
81/18
Panna Lal Vs
NDMC &Ors
Smt.
Bindiya
Savara
Land
Dispute
Notice
Received on
dated
18.03.2019
16.01.2020
35 Directorate of
Health Services
Saikh
Sarai
CC/59
0/18
Rxxx Vs
GNCTD
Bindiya
savara
Medical
Negligence Evidence 03.12.2019
36 Directorate of
Health Services
Finance
Commissio
ner
Naveen Khichi Vs
DHS Smt.
Bindiya
Savara
De-
registratio
n of
Nursing
Home
Misc.
arguments
12.12.2019
37 Directorate of
Health Services
Tis Hazari Executi
on no
801/18
Bansal Genral
Store Vs
DHS&Ors
Smt.
Bindiya
Savara
Payments
against
supply
Disposed on
11.10.2019
38 Directorate of
Health Services
Tis Hazari Executi
on no
313/19
V.P.Jain Vs
GNCTD
Smt.
Bindiya
Savara
Payments
against
supply
Misc purpose
15.11.2019
