Enel-Anselmo Nucleare

8/14/2019 Enel-Anselmo Nucleare

1/69

Language E Safety Class SEC. INDEX Company

use/P

Submitted to

Client for :

ApprovalInformation

Only

The SE a.s. approval refers to the contract clauses only.All design responsibilities are charged to the Contractor .

EPS No. PNM3!"!# $evision in%e& "" Si'e A(tivityCo%e

)ype*

Su+type

Dis(ipline Plant,nit

-ile Name SE %o(. Co%e PNM3!/"3 A4 T P !

PNM3462210300_E.doc

S0eet

OfPlant

SystemCompon

ent

" 69

ESITO SUPERVISIONE

Supervision Outcome

REVDATADate

IssuePurpose

ESAMINATOSupervised by

COLLABORAZIONICo-operations

APPROVATOApproved by

EMESSO

Issued by

DIVISIONE INGEGNERIA E RICERCAAREA TECNICA NUCLEARE

Documento / #ocument no

MOHPB050103

Indice SicurezzaSecurity $nde%

Compa! "#$%p

INOLTRO A IR/ATNSubmittal TO IR/ ATN [X]

PER APPROVAZIONE

For approval[]

PER INFORMAZIONE

Fori information

NON RICHIESTO

Not requested

SISTEMASystem

00A TIPO DOCUMENTODoument type

TL DISCIPLINADisipline

I FILE MOHPB05010300.DOCFile

COMPONENTEComponent

LOTTO!ot

CONTRATTO N.Subontrat

Lapprova!o"e #! IR / ATN $ %!&!'a'a a(%! aspe''! re%a'!v! a%%epres)r!!o"! )o"'ra''ua%!* r!&a"(o"o per'a"'o a )ar!)o #e%For"!'ore 'u''e %e respo"sa+!%!', #e%%a pro(e''a!o"e.

T-e IR / ATN approva% reers 'o )o"'ra)'ua% reu!re&e"'s a"#)%auses o"%0. A%% #es!(" respo"s!+!%!'!es re&a!" )-ar(e# 'o '-eSupp%!er.

PRO1ETTO"ro#et Moc&o'c$ 3(4 N"c)$a* I#)ad + H,-& E$*-! P,p$ B*$a Aa)!#,#

TITOLOTitle

Roo& A232/4 5 6ua%!'a'!ve Assess&e"' o7A((ress!ve8 PBL

CLIENTEO$ner

SLOVENS9E ELE9TRARNE

:OB "o ;


2/69

Una Societ Finmeccanica

T,is doument is property of (nel In)e)neria e Riera Spa* It is stritly forbidden to reprodue t,is doument. $,olly or partially. and toprovide any related information to ot,ers $it,out previous $ritten onsent*


3/69


P*o-$//oproject Mochoce !"# Nuc$ear I%$and

&i'h Ener'( )ipe *rea+ Ana$(%i%

Id$/,,ca/,'odocument no,

M-&)*..0.#C),$/$ ENELcu%tomer DI1ISI-NE IN2E2NERIA E RICERCA

AREA TECNICA NUCLEARE

S,#/$ma%(%,

Comm.+S.comm.jo3, no,

ANN0..#

Em,//$/$i%%ued 3(

IMN

Pa-,apa'e

4

D,o5

69Ra-. Soc. o*,/o*$%upp$ier%

S,-)acode

Id$/. $#/$*o % R$'.%upp$ier ident, / re,

C). *,#.c$a%%

4

,po doc.doc t(pe

TL

O*d,$ a//,'o % Co/*a//oorder

#7..0.!09 ar,0! 8 4./04/4.04

Id$/,,ca/,'o Compo$/$euipment identi5, code

,/o)otit$e

So#/,/",#c$%u3%titute%

Ca/.%ite

IER

/

o*.%upp$ier

%

A#a)do

E

C),$/$cu%tomer

ANo/$note%

EECRONICIENAME M-&)*..0.# :Ripri%tinato; :Ripri%tinato;49#00..44#.#9,doc EECRONICORMADESCRIPION

R$'.re.

R,. App*o'. A#a)doAn%a$do0 M-&)*..0.# :Ripri%tinato; :Ripri%tinato;49#00..44#.#9,doc


4/69


P*o-$//o)roject Mochoce !"# Nuc$ear I%$and


Id$/,,ca/,'oDocument no,

M-&)*..0.#

R$'.Re,

..

C). *,#.c$a%%

4

Pa-,a)a'e

4

C*oo)o-,a $ #/o*,a d$))$ *$',#,o,

Chrono$o'( and hi%tor( o5 rei%ion%

R$'./ re, Da/a/date

D$#c*,,o$/de%cription

.. 18/01/2013 FIRST ISSUE

ANN.09>0 M-&)*..0.# :Ripri%tinato;:Ripri%tinato;49#00..44#.#9,doc


5/69





M-&)*..0.#

R$'.Re,

..

C). *,#.c$a%%

4

Pa-,a)a'e

5

a7)$ o Co/$/#

BAC8GRO9ND AND P9RPOSE.........................................................................10

1.1 BAC8GRO9ND ..............................................................................................10

1.2 P9RPOSE .......................................................................................................10

1.3 BASIC CONSIDERAIONS ............................................................................10

:9AIAIVE ASSESSMEN O AGGRESSIVE PIPE BREA8 INES............12

1.4 ASSESSMEN O INE 1 BRANCH 38B50BR005; ERMINA END38B50%04_B1 .....................................................................................................13

1.5 ASSESSMEN O INE 10 BRANCH 38B10BR001; ERMINA END38B10%01_B1 .....................................................................................................1NB60%01_B1 .....................................................................................................2?

1.? ASSESSMEN O INE 2NG12BR001; ERMINA END3>NG12%02_B1 .....................................................................................................32

1.10 ASSESSMEN O INE 2NG12BR002; ERMINA END3>NG12%04_B1 .....................................................................................................35

1.11 ASSESSMEN O INE 2NG13BR001; ERMINA END3>NG13%01_B1 .....................................................................................................3?

1.12 ASSESSMEN O INE 2NG13BR002; ERMINA END3>NG13%03_B1 .....................................................................................................42

1.13 ASSESSMEN O INE 2NG61BR01NG61%01_B1 .....................................................................................................45

1.14 ASSESSMEN O INE =4 BRANCH 38B10BR002; ERMINA END38B10%02_B1 .....................................................................................................4?

1.15 ASSESSMEN O INE =4 BRANCH 38B10BR004; ERMINA END38B10%03_B1 .....................................................................................................53

1.16 ASSESSMEN O INE =4 BRANCH 38B50BR002; ERMINA END38B50%02_B1 .....................................................................................................50 M-&)*..0.# :Ripri%tinato;:Ripri%tinato;49#00..44#.#9,doc


6/69





M-&)*..0.#

R$'.Re,

..

C). *,#.c$a%%

4

Pa-,a)a'e

6

1.1? DOC9MENS ...............................................................................................60 M-&)*..0.# :Ripri%tinato;:Ripri%tinato;49#00..44#.#9,doc


7/69





M-&)*..0.#

R$'.Re,

..

C). *,#.c$a%%

4

Pa-,a)a'e

hip

An%lsis #epo#ts see #ef. 1.17fo# #oo" A203/1 (he#e%s the st#ess %n%lses #epo#ts #ef. 1.17 c%n %ct!%ll

follo( % iffe#ent piping lines n!"'e#ing.

The l%o!t of s%fet #ele$%nt co"ponents is infe##e f#o" the pl%nt 3D "oel #ef. 1.17%n f#o" %$%il%'le

l%o!t #%(ings see #ef. 1.17 fo# #oo" A203/1.

It is possi'le th%t the pl%nt 3D "oel #ef. 1.17sho(s so"e inconsistenc %n the l%o!t #%(ings o not

sho( %ll co"ponents incl!e in the t%#get list #ef. 1.17? in s!ch c%ses the concl!sions of this &!%lit%ti$e

%ssess"ent h%$e to 'e consie#e p#eli"in%#. An #ele$%nt inconsistenc #es!lting f#o" the pl%nt 3D "oel

#ef.1.17inspection (ill 'e pointe o!t in this #epo#t.



12/69





M-&)*..0.#

R$'.Re,

..

C). *,#.c$a%%

4

Pa-,a)a'e

12

:9AIAIVE ASSESSMEN O AGGRESSIVE PIPE BREA8 INES

The e$%l!%tion of the potenti%l i"p%ct of post!l%te pipe '#e%,s on ite"s i"po#t%nt to s%fet is '%se on the

follo(ing si"plifing %n conse#$%ti$e %ss!"ptions?follo(ing %n high ene#g line '#e%, it is %ss!"e th%t

the !n#est#%ine pipe '#o,en en st%#ts to #ot%te %#o!n % pl%stic hinge fo#"e %long the '#o,en line.

The pl%stic hinge loc%tion %long the (hipping pipe is co"p!te %cco#ing to the "ethos o!tline in #ef

1.17@

%s % gene#%l c%se %ll co"ponents loc%te (ithin % sphe#ic%l $ol!"e cent#e %t the pl%stic hinge %n (ith

#%i!s e&!%l to the ist%nce 'et(een the pl%stic hinge loc%tion %n the '#o,en te#"in%l en %#e consie#e

potenti%ll %ffecte ' the (hipping pipe. This is % conse#$%ti$e %ss!"ption since the (hipping pipe "otion

is not e9pecte to 'e co"pletel !n#est#%ine. )o(e$e# (itho!t pipe (hip #est#%ints the '#o,en en "otion

fo# l%#ge ispl%ce"ents is iffic!lt to p#eict since fo# % tpic%l piping l%o!t it c%n 'e sho(n th%t the

'#o,en pipe t#%-ecto# is not cont%ine in % single pl%n see %lso #ef.1.17.

o#eo$e# the i"p%ct (ith othe# pipe lines %n co"ponents c%n "oif the st%#ting te#"in%l en t#%-ecto# of

%n !n#est#%ine '#%nch. >he#e the l%o!t of '#%nches %ffecte ' the post!l%te '#e%, is si"ple %n

cont%ine in % single pl%n the %ssess"ent is '%se on less conse#$%ti$e %ss!"ptions see #ef. 1.17%n the

follo(ing sections.

o %tte"pt is "%e to co"p!te the fo#ces #es!lting f#o" the i"p%ct of the (hipping pipe on ne%#' S%fet

SSs@ it h%s 'een s%fel %ss!"e th%t (hene$e# %n i"p%ct 'et(een the (hipping pipe %n % c#itic%l

co"ponent occ!#s '%se on %'o$e "entione l%o!t consie#%tions the t%#get ite" in$ol$e is so"e(h%t

%ffecte %n potenti%ll %"%ge e9cept (he#e the t%#get co"ponent is % pipe line (ith l%#ge# si:e

co"p%#e to the '#o,en pipe see #ef.1.17.

The effect of fl!i -et i"pinge"ent on s%fet SSs is o!t of the scope of this oc!"ent %n (ill not 'e t%,en

into %cco!nt fo# the '#e%, 4%gg#essi$e5 %ssess"ent.

The )igh Ene#g ines to 'e in$estig%te %s potenti%l 4%gg#essi$e5 pipe '#e%,s in #oo" A203/1 %#e ine 2


13/69





M-&)*..0.#

R$'.Re,

..

C). *,#.c$a%%

4

Pa-,a)a'e

13

1.4 ASSESSMEN O INE 1 BRANCH 38B50BR005; ERMINA END 38B50%04_B1

sho(s the te#"in%l en 3B10/02C+1 '#%nch 3B10+R002 %n its s!##o!ning.

Acco#ing to #ef. 1.17the pipe line '#e%, is post!l%te to occ!# in co##esponence of this te#"in%l en.

sho(s %lso %n inic%ti$e position fo# the pl%stic hinge fo#"%tion. A &!%ntit%ti$e e$%l!%tion th%t sho(s (he#e

pl%stic hinge fo#"s %long '#%nch 3B10+R002 is #epo#te in #ef. 1.17.

A possi'le pipe (hip t#%-ecto# %n the %#e% %ffecte ' the !n#est#%ine "otion of the '#o,en te#"in%l en

%#e %lso s,etche in %.. The piping l%o!t of this po#tion of line 2< is not cont%ine in % single pl%n the#e' it

is s%fe# to %ss!"e th%t co"ponents incl!e (ithin % sphe#ic%l $ol!"e cent#e on pl%stic hinge loc%tion c%n

'e potenti%ll i"p%cte

The fig!#e sho(s th%t se$e#%l pipe '#%nches %n co"ponents co!l 'e i#ectl i"p%cte ' the (hipping

pipe.the )#o%cc!"!l%to#s %n the pipe '#%nches 3B11+R002 3B21+R01 3B12+R001 %n

3+20+R001 see T%'le 262 .

The co"ponents %n the $%l$e on the %'o$e pipe lines %#e incl!e in the t%#get list of s%fet #el%te ite"s

#ef.1.17

As % conse&!ence the post!l%te pipe '#e%, occ!##ing %t te#"in%l en 3B10/02C+1 sho!l 'e consie#e

4%gg#essi$e5 %t this st%ge. F!#the# %n%lses consie#ing -et i"pinge"ent effects on ne%#' co"ponents %n

on the (%lls #est#%ining (hipping pipe "otion %#e #e&!i#e fo# % fin%l pipe '#e%, cl%ssific%tion.

T%'le 261#epo#ts the #ele$%nt %t% fo# the %n%l:e pipe '#e%,. T%'le 262 cont%ins % list of co"ponents th%t

c%n 'e potenti%ll %ffecte ' (hipping pipe "otion.

Ta3$e 4Ta3$e 48800?? Re5erence Data 5or *ranchRe5erence Data 5or *ranch !@*.*R..!@*.*R.. )ipe *rea+)ipe *rea+

Line - BranchDiameter

[mm]

Thickness

[mm]

Oeratin!

Press"re

[#Pa]

Oeratin!

Temerat"r

e [$C]

%i&e' P(int ID)Termina* En'

ID

3;+F0+R00 0. 9 12.2 2 3;+F0+001/)3 3;+F0/0


14/69





M-&)*..0.#

R$'.Re,

..

C). *,#.c$a%%

4

Pa-,a)a'e

14

i'ure 4i'ure 48800a? hippin' motion 5or *rancha? hippin' motion 5or *ranch !@*.*R..!@*.*R.. at the corre%pondin' TEat the corre%pondin' TE !@*./.#>*0!@*./.#>*0


!@*.*R..

!@*.*C..0

!@*.*C..4

3KBF50/04_B

Plastic hinge

location

(hipping pipemotion


15/69





M-&)*..0.#

R$'.Re,

..

C). *,#.c$a%%

4

Pa-,a)a'e

15

i'ure 4i'ure 488443? hippin' motion 5or *ranch3? hippin' motion 5or *ranch !@*.*R..!@*.*R.. at the corre%pondin' TEat the corre%pondin' TE !@*./.#>*0!@*./.#>*0


.E!@*.*R..

!@U*.!AA..4

!@U*.0AA..4

!@U*.4AA..4

[email protected]

!@*.*R.4!


16/69





M-&)*..0.#

R$'.Re,

..

C). *,#.c$a%%

4

Pa-,a)a'e

16

Ta3$e 4Ta3$e 48844?Li%t o5 component% a55ected 3( a po%tu$ated 3rea+ at TE !@*./.#>*0?Li%t o5 component% a55ected 3( a po%tu$ated 3rea+ at TE !@*./.#>*0

C(m(nent ID ItemDiameter

[mm]

Thickness

[mm]DPS

Direct*+

Imacte'C*assi,icati(n

38B50BC001 &eat echan'er 8 8 !,.!,.0 e% Critica$

38B50BC002


17/69





M-&)*..0.#

R$'.Re,

..

C). *,#.c$a%%

4

Pa-,a)a'e

1*0!@*0./.0>*0

Compo$/ ID I/$mD,am$/$*

mm&,c$##

mmDPS

D,*$c/)!Impac/$d

C)a##,,ca/,o4

38B10BC001&eat

echan'er8 8 !,.!,.0 e% Critica$

38B10BC002 A5tercoo$er 8 8 !,.!,.0 e% Critica$

38AA10BR015.50 )ipe *ranch !,04,.0 e% Critica$

38B10BR014 )ipe *ranch !,.!,.0 e% Critica$

38B10BR006 )ipe *ranch

!,.!,.0 e% Critica$.KB%)1AA)16 7a8 1a$e + +

.KB%)1AA)12 798 1a$e + +

38B10BR023 )ipe *ranch !,.!,.0 e% Critica$

#accordin' to re5, 0,09



21/69





M-&)*..0.#

R$'.Re,

..

C). *,#.c$a%%

4

Pa-,a)a'e

21

1.6 ASSESSMEN O INE 12 BRANCH 38B10BR005; ERMINA END 38B10%04_B1

Fig!#e 263 %' sho( the te#"in%l en 3B21 01C+1 of pipe line 2


22/69





M-&)*..0.#

R$'.Re,

..

C). *,#.c$a%%

4

Pa-,a)a'e

22

i'ure 4i'ure 488a? hippin' motion 5or *ranch !@*0.*R.. at the corre%pondin' TE !@*0./.#>*0a? hippin' motion 5or *ranch !@*0.*R.. at the corre%pondin' TE !@*0./.#>*0


Plastic hingelocation

!*+,"-/-4+!@*0.*R..0/.0

!@*0.*C..0

3;+F10+R00

!@*0.*C..4

3PER


23/69





M-&)*..0.#

R$'.Re,

..

C). *,#.c$a%%

4

Pa-,a)a'e

23

i'ure 4i'ure 488663? hippin' motion 5or *ranch !@*0.*R.. at the corre%pondin' TE !@*0./.#>*03? hippin' motion 5or *ranch !@*0.*R.. at the corre%pondin' TE !@*0./.#>*0


.E

3;+F10+R00

3;+F20+R001

3;+F0+R001

3GS10+R001

3GS0+R00

3;+F10+R023


24/69





M-&)*..0.#

R$'.Re,

..

C). *,#.c$a%%

4

Pa-,a)a'e

24

Ta3$e 4Ta3$e 48866? Li%t o5 component% a55ected 3( a po%tu$ated 3rea+ at TE !@*0./.#>*0? Li%t o5 component% a55ected 3( a po%tu$ated 3rea+ at TE !@*0./.#>*0


[mm]

Thickness

[mm]DPS

Direct*+

Imacte'C*assi,icati(n2

38B10BC001 &eat echan'er 6 6

!,.!,.0 Hes Critica$

38B10BC002 A5tercoo$er 6 6

3:>S60BR005 )ipe *ranch 6 6 !,0#,.0 Hes Not Critica$

3:>S10BR001 )ipe *ranch 6 6 !,.0,. Hes Not Critica$

38BE11BR005 )ipe *ranch 6 6 !,.0,.! Hes Critica$

3PER4?BR001 )ipe *ranch 6 6 !,.6,.0 ot Critica$

3PER4?BR002 )ipe *ranch 6 6 !,.6,.0 ot Critica$

3GHC1?BR001 )ipe *ranch Hes Not Critica$

38A14BR001%01 )ipe *ranch !,0#,.0 ot Critica$

6accordin' to re5, 0,09



25/69





M-&)*..0.#

R$'.Re,

..

C). *,#.c$a%%

4

Pa-,a)a'e

25

1.< ASSESSMEN O INE 14 BRANCH 38B50BR001; ERMINA END 38B50%01_B1

Fig!#e 26< %' sho( the te#"in%l en 3+20 01C+1 of pipe line 2


26/69





M-&)*..0.#

R$'.Re,

..

C). *,#.c$a%%

4

Pa-,a)a'e

26

i'ure 4i'ure 488GGa? hippin' motion 5or *ranch !@*.*R..0 at the corre%pondin' TE !@*./.0>*0a? hippin' motion 5or *ranch !@*.*R..0 at the corre%pondin' TE !@*./.0>*0


3;+F10+R00


!*+,-/-"+

3;+F0+002 3;+F0+001

3;+F0+R023

3;+F0+R00

3;+F0+R00

3;+F0+R002

(hippingpipe motion


27/69





M-&)*..0.#

R$'.Re,

..

C). *,#.c$a%%

4

Pa-,a)a'e

2*0a? hippin' motion 5or *ranch !@*.*R..0 at the corre%pondin' TE !@*./.0>*0


3;+F10+R00

3;+F0+R01*0!HN*6./.0>*0

Compo$/ID

I/$mD,am$/$*

mm&,c$##

mmDPS

D,*$c/)!Impac/$d

C)a##,,ca/,o10

3C:12BR001 )ipe *ranch Hes ot #itic%l

38A11BR033 )ipe *ranch3.01.0

Hes ot #itic%l

3>NB60BR00< )ipe *ranch3.1NG61BR01< )ipe *ranch o o #itic%l

38A12BR003 )ipe *ranch 3.0.01

Hes o #itic%l38A12AA006aF

%l$e 6 6

38A11BR011 )ipe *ranch 3.0.0

1Hes o #itic%l38A11AA00?

7F%l$e 6 6

0.accordin' to re5,0,09



32/69





M-&)*..0.#

R$'.Re,

..

C). *,#.c$a%%

4

Pa-,a)a'e

32

1.? ASSESSMEN O INE 2NG12BR001; ERMINA END 3>NG12%02_B1

Fig!#e 26 %' sho( the te#"in%l en 3B12/01C+1 of pipe line 20 M-&)*..0.# :Ripri%tinato;:Ripri%tinato;49#00..44#.#9,doc


33/69





M-&)*..0.#

R$'.Re,

..

C). *,#.c$a%%

4

Pa-,a)a'e

33

i'ure 4i'ure 4880.0.aJ3? hippin' motion 5or *ranch !HN204*R..0,.0 at the corre%pondin' TEaJ3? hippin' motion 5or *ranch !HN204*R..0,.0 at the corre%pondin' TE!HN204/.4>*0!HN204/.4>*0


(hipping pipemotion

!HN204*R..0

TE !0)1"2/-2+"


!@*0!*R..0 !@*04*R..0

!@*04*R..0


34/69





M-&)*..0.#

R$'.Re,

..

C). *,#.c$a%%

4

Pa-,a)a'e

34

Ta3$e 4Ta3$e 4880404? Li%t o5 component% a55ected 3( a po%tu$ated 3rea+ at TE !HN204/.4>*0? Li%t o5 component% a55ected 3( a po%tu$ated 3rea+ at TE !HN204/.4>*0

Compo$/ ID I/$mD,am$/$*

mm&,c$##

mmDPS

D,*$c/)!Impac/$d

C)a##,,ca/,o12

3>NG10BR002 )ipe *ranch 4G! 4. !,0#,.0 e% Critica$

3>NG11BR002 )ipe *ranch 4G! 4. !,0#,.0 e% Critica$

3>NB20BR001 )ipe *ranch 4G! 4. !,0#,.0 e% Critica$

38B12BR001 )ipe *ranch )ot available !,.0,.G e% Critica$

38B12BR002 )ipe *ranch )ot available !,.0,.G e% Critica$

38A14BR001.03 )ipe *ranch 0 4,6 !,0#,.0 No No Critica$

3:>S60BR003 )ipe *ranch !4 !, 8 No No Critica$

04accordin' to re5,0,09



35/69





M-&)*..0.#

R$'.Re,

..

C). *,#.c$a%%

4

Pa-,a)a'e

35

1.10 ASSESSMEN O INE 2NG12BR002; ERMINA END 3>NG12%04_B1



36/69





M-&)*..0.#

R$'.Re,

..

C). *,#.c$a%%

4

Pa-,a)a'e

36


(hipping pipemotion

!0)1"!/-"+"


.E

3>NG13BR001

3>NG12BR002

!0)1"!/-"+"

!0)1"2/-4+"

3>NG12BR002

!0)1"2++--"3>NG13BR001

3>NB60BR001

3>NG12BR001.01

3>NB61BR01NG12BB001 H!d*oacc"m")a/o* + +3.14.01

@$# C*,/,ca)

3>NG13BR001 P,p$ B*ac&3.14.01

@$# C*,/,ca)

3>NG13BR002 P,p$ B*ac&

3>NB61BR01< P,p$ B*ac&

3>NG61AA013aF Va)'$

3>NB60BR001 P,p$ B*ac&

3:BR24BR001.01 P,p$ B*ac&

0#accordin' to re5,0,09



39/69





M-&)*..0.#

R$'.Re,

..

C). *,#.c$a%%

4

Pa-,a)a'e

3?




40/69





M-&)*..0.#

R$'.Re,

..

C). *,#.c$a%%

4

Pa-,a)a'e

40

i'ure 4i'ure 4880404aJ3? hippin' motion 5or *ranch !HN20!*R..0 at the corre%pondin' TEaJ3? hippin' motion 5or *ranch !HN20!*R..0 at the corre%pondin' TE!HN20!/.0>*0!HN20!/.0>*0


(hippingi e motion

!0)1"!/-"+"


3>MN41BR002+01

3>NG13BR001

3>NG13BR001

3>NG13BR002

3>NG61BR01MN41AA004

38A12AP001


41/69





M-&)*..0.#

R$'.Re,

..

C). *,#.c$a%%

4

Pa-,a)a'e

41

Ta3$e 4Ta3$e 4880606? Li%t o5 component% a55ected 3( a po%tu$ated 3rea+ at TE !HN20!/.0>*0? Li%t o5 component% a55ected 3( a po%tu$ated 3rea+ at TE !HN20!/.0>*0


[mm]

Thickness

[mm]DPS

Direct*+

Imacte'C*assi,icati(n)2

.;NG)1BR11 Pipe +#%nch 23 203.1


42/69





M-&)*..0.#

R$'.Re,

..

C). *,#.c$a%%

4

Pa-,a)a'e

42




43/69





M-&)*..0.#

R$'.Re,

..

C). *,#.c$a%%

4

Pa-,a)a'e

43

i'ure 4i'ure 4880!0!aJ3? hippin' motion 5or *ranch !HN20!*R..4 at the corre%pondin' TEaJ3? hippin' motion 5or *ranch !HN20!*R..4 at the corre%pondin' TE!HN20!/.!>*0!HN20!/.!>*0


(hipping pipemotion

3:>S60BR00338A14BR001.03

!0)1"!/-!+"


(hipping pipe motion

3>NG13BR002

!0)1"!++--"

3>NG13BR002

3>NG12BR002

3>NG12AA001

3>NG12AA002

b

b

a

a

3>NB60BR001

c

3>NB60AA001

c

d

3>NB60AA002

d

38B12BR001

38B12BR002

3>NB60BR001

.E


44/69





M-&)*..0.#

R$'.Re,

..

C). *,#.c$a%%

4

Pa-,a)a'e

44

Ta3$e 4Ta3$e 48800? Li%t o5 component% a55ected 3( a po%tu$ated 3rea+ at TE !HN20!/.!>*0? Li%t o5 component% a55ected 3( a po%tu$ated 3rea+ at TE !HN20!/.!>*0


[mm]

Thickness

[mm]DPS

Direct*+

Imacte'C*assi,icati(n)6

.;NG)1BR11 Pipe +#%nch 23 203.1


45/69





M-&)*..0.#

R$'.Re,

..

C). *,#.c$a%%

4

Pa-,a)a'e

45

1.13 ASSESSMEN O INE 2NG61BR01NG61%01_B1



46/69





M-&)*..0.#

R$'.Re,

..

C). *,#.c$a%%

4

Pa-,a)a'e

46


(hipping pipemotion

!*+,"-/-!+"

Plastic hingelocation3>NG61BR01NG61BR01MN61AA004

3:BR50BR001

3>E11BR004+0023:>S10BR001

3C:12BR001

3>NB60BR001

3SR831BR022

38A11BR033.0=


47/69





M-&)*..0.#

R$'.Re,

..

C). *,#.c$a%%

4

Pa-,a)a'e

4*0!HN260/.0>*0



48/69





M-&)*..0.#

R$'.Re,

..

C). *,#.c$a%%

4

Pa-,a)a'e

4=

Ta3$e 4Ta3$e 4884.4.? Li%t o5 component% a55ected 3( a po%tu$ated 3rea+ at TE !HN260/.0>*0? Li%t o5 component% a55ected 3( a po%tu$ated 3rea+ at TE !HN260/.0>*0


[mm]

Thickness

[mm]DPS

Direct*+


.;NG)1BR11 Pipe +#%nch 23 203.1


49/69





M-&)*..0.#

R$'.Re,

..

C). *,#.c$a%%

4

Pa-,a)a'e

4?

1.14 ASSESSMEN O INE =4 BRANCH 38B10BR002; ERMINA END 38B10%02_B1



50/69





M-&)*..0.#

R$'.Re,

..

C). *,#.c$a%%

4

Pa-,a)a'e

50

i'ure 4i'ure 48800a? hippin' motion 5or *ranch !@*0.*R..4 at the corre%pondin' TE !@*0./.4>*0a? hippin' motion 5or *ranch !@*0.*R..4 at the corre%pondin' TE !@*0./.4>*0


(hipping pipemotion


!@*0.*R..4

!*+,"-/-!+"

!*+,"-+C--2

!@*0.*R..#

!@*0.*R..0/.0

!@UA.*R.0

!@*.*R.0#


51/69





M-&)*..0.#

R$'.Re,

..

C). *,#.c$a%%

4

Pa-,a)a'e

51

i'ure 4i'ure 48806063? hippin' motion 5or *ranch !@*0.*R..4 at the corre%pondin' TE !@*0./.4>*03? hippin' motion 5or *ranch !@*0.*R..4 at the corre%pondin' TE !@*0./.4>*0


.E

!@*0.*R..4

!*+,"-+C--2

!@*0.*R..G

/!@AA0.*R.0#,0.


52/69





M-&)*..0.#

R$'.Re,

..

C). *,#.c$a%%

4

Pa-,a)a'e

52

Ta3$e 4Ta3$e 4884444? Li%t o5 component% a55ected 3( a po%tu$ated 3rea+ at TE !@*0./.4>*0? Li%t o5 component% a55ected 3( a po%tu$ated 3rea+ at TE !@*0./.4>*0


[mm]

Thickness

[mm]DPS

Direct*+

Imacte'C*assi,icati(n

.;NG)1BR11 Pipe +#%nch 23 203.1


53/69





M-&)*..0.#

R$'.Re,

..

C). *,#.c$a%%

4

Pa-,a)a'e

53

1.15 ASSESSMEN O INE =4 BRANCH 38B10BR004; ERMINA END 38B10%03_B1



54/69





M-&)*..0.#

R$'.Re,

..

C). *,#.c$a%%

4

Pa-,a)a'e

54



55/69





M-&)*..0.#

R$'.Re,

..

C). *,#.c$a%%

4

Pa-,a)a'e

55

i'ure 4i'ure 4880G0GaJ3? hippin' motion 5or *ranch !@*0.*R..# at the corre%pondin' TEaJ3? hippin' motion 5or *ranch !@*0.*R..# at the corre%pondin' TE

!@*0./.!>*0!@*0./.!>*0


!*+,"-/-!+"


(hipping pipemotion

38B10BR004

.E

38B10BR004

38AA10BR015.10

38AA10BR015.50

38AA10BR014.50

!*+,"-+C--"


56/69





M-&)*..0.#

R$'.Re,

..

C). *,#.c$a%%

4

Pa-,a)a'e

56

Ta3$e 4Ta3$e 4884#4#? Li%t o5 component% a55ected 3( a po%tu$ated 3rea+ at TE !@*0./.!>*0? Li%t o5 component% a55ected 3( a po%tu$ated 3rea+ at TE !@*0./.!>*0


[mm]

Thickness

[mm]DPS

Direct*+


.;NG)1BR11 Pipe +#%nch 23 203.1


57/69





M-&)*..0.#

R$'.Re,

..

C). *,#.c$a%%

4

Pa-,a)a'e

50 M-&)*..0.# :Ripri%tinato;:Ripri%tinato;49#00..44#.#9,doc

(hipping pipemotion

38B10BR004

!*+,-/-2+"


.E

(hipping pipemotion

!@*.*R..4

!@*.*C..4

!@*.*R..G

!@*.*R..0

!@*.*R.0#

!@*.*C..4


59/69





M-&)*..0.#

R$'.Re,

..

C). *,#.c$a%%

4

Pa-,a)a'e

5?

i'ure 4i'ure 48800aJ3? hippin' motion 5or *ranchaJ3? hippin' motion 5or *ranch !@*.*R..4!@*.*R..4at the corre%pondin' TEat the corre%pondin' TE

!@*./.4>*0!@*./.4>*0



60/69





M-&)*..0.#

R$'.Re,

..

C). *,#.c$a%%

4

Pa-,a)a'e

60

Ta3$e 4Ta3$e 4884646? Li%t o5 component% a55ected 3( a po%tu$ated 3rea+ at TE? Li%t o5 component% a55ected 3( a po%tu$ated 3rea+ at TE !@*./.4>*0!@*./.4>*0


[mm]

Thickness

[mm]DPS

Direct*+


.;NG)1BR11 Pipe +#%nch 23 203.1


61/69





M-&)*..0.#

R$'.Re,

..

C). *,#.c$a%%

4

Pa-,a)a'e

61

1.1< ASSESSMEN O INE =4 BRANCH 38B50BR004; ERMINA END 38B50%03_B1



62/69





M-&)*..0.#

R$'.Re,

..

C). *,#.c$a%%

4

Pa-,a)a'e

62


(hipping pipemotion

!@*.*R..#

!*+,-/-!+"


!@TA0#*R..0/.0

!@*.*R..#

.E

!)ER#9*R..4

!*+,-+C--"/62

!)ER#9*R..0

!2&C09*R..0

!HE00*R..


63/69





M-&)*..0.#

R$'.Re,

..

C). *,#.c$a%%

4

Pa-,a)a'e

63

i'ure 4i'ure 4880909aJ3? hippin' motion 5or *ranchaJ3? hippin' motion 5or *ranch !@*.*R..#!@*.*R..#at the corre%pondin' TEat the corre%pondin' TE

!@*./.!>*0!@*./.!>*0



64/69





M-&)*..0.#

R$'.Re,

..

C). *,#.c$a%%

4

Pa-,a)a'e

64

Ta3$e 4Ta3$e 48844? Li%t o5 component% a55ected 3( a po%tu$ated 3rea+ at TE? Li%t o5 component% a55ected 3( a po%tu$ated 3rea+ at TE !@*./.!>*0!@*./.!>*0


[mm]

Thickness

[mm]DPS

Direct*+


.;NG)1BR11 Pipe +#%nch 23 203.1


65/69





M-&)*..0.#

R$'.Re,

..

C). *,#.c$a%%

4

Pa-,a)a'e

65

CONC9SION AND RECOMMENDAION

)igh Ene#g ines loc%te (ithin #oo" A203/1 of !cle%# Isl%n of ocho$ce !cle%# Po(e# Pl%nt !nit 3

h%$e 'een in$estig%te loo,ing fo# pipe '#e%,s th%t c%n #es!lt in potenti%l %"%ge of ne%#' co"ponents.

Pipe +#e%,s t#igge#ing pipe (hip th%t c%n %ffect pipe6line o# s%fet #ele$%nt co"ponents see #ef. 1.17fo# %

co"plete list %#e consie#e 4%gg#essi$e5.

The ientific%tion of co"ponents th%t c%n 'e %ffecte ' the high ene#g lines pipe (hip is '%se on

si"plifie %ss!"ptions %'o!t te#"in%l ens "otion %n on sste" l%o!t infe##e f#o" the 3D "oel #ef.

1.17.

T%'le 3627#epo#ts % s!""%# of the G!%lit%ti$e Assess"ent finings fo# #oo" A203/1.

The concl!sions of this #epo#t h%$e to 'e consie#e p#eli"in%# since %ll consie#%tions %#e '%se on the

l%o!t infe##e f#o" p#eli"in%# 3D "oel see #ef. 1.17 %n the effects of -et i"pinge"ent %#e not

incl!e.

The concl!sions of this #epo#t %#e '%se on % &!%lit%ti$e %ssess"ent %n % si"plifie conse#$%ti$e %pp#o%ch.

Refine %n%lses p#o$iing "o#e %cc!#%te info#"%tion %'o!t (hipping pipe n%"ics %n %pplie lo%s on

ne%#' co"ponents c%n 'e pe#fo#"e (he#e$e# the %ssess"ent concl!sions %#e ee"e too conse#$%ti$e.

Ta3$e !Ta3$e !884949? Summar( o5 Fua$itatie A%%e%%ment 5or 3ranche% Bithin room A4.!/0? Summar( o5 Fua$itatie A%%e%%ment 5or 3ranche% Bithin room A4.!/0

BranchDiameter

[mm]

Termina* En'

IDC*assi,icati(n

3B10+R002 23 3B10 02C+1 4Agg#essi$e5

3B11+R002 23 3B11 02C+1 4Agg#essi$e5

3B21+R01 23 3B21 01C+1 4Agg#essi$e5

3+20+R001 23 3+20 01C+1 4Agg#essi$e5

3B12+R001 87 3B12 01C+1 4Agg#essi$e5



66/69





M-&)*..0.#

R$'.Re,

..

C). *,#.c$a%%

4

Pa-,a)a'e

66

REERENCES

1.1= CODES

/0/, ANSI/AISC N69.8099# K American Nationa$ Standard Speci5ication 5or the De%i'nJ a3rication and

Erection o5 Stee$ Sa5et(8Re$ated Structure% 5or Nuc$ear aci$itie%

/4/, ANSI 8 American Nationa$ Standard In%titute ANSI *0,0 and *0,4 099 Edition

/!/, ANSI/ASME *!0,0 Code 5or )re%%ure )ipin'J 099 Edition

/#/, ANSI/ANS 84 American Nuc$ear Societ(/American Nuc$ear Standard KDe%i'n *a%i% 5or )rotection

o5 Li'ht ater Nuc$ear )oBer )$ant A'ain%t the E55ect o5 )o%tu$ated )ipe Rupture% 09 Edition

//, ASME *oi$er and )re%%ure 1e%%e$ Code, Section IIIJ Dii%ion 0J Su38Section%J N*J NC JNDJ N "

Appendice% 4..G Edition

/6/, U,S, Nuc$ear Re'u$ator( Commi%%ion NURE28...J *ranch Technica$ )o%ition !8! K)rotection

A'ain%t )o%tu$ated )ipin' ai$ure% in $uid S(%tem% -ut%ide Containment Re, !J March 4..G

/G/, U,S, Nuc$ear Re'u$ator( Commi%%ion NURE28...J *ranch Technica$ )o%ition !8# K )o%tu$ated

Rupture $ocation% in $uid S(%tem )ipin' In%ide and -ut%ide Containment Re, 4J March 4..G

//, U,S, Nuc$ear Re'u$ator( Commi%%ion NURE28...J Standard ReieB )$an !,6,4J KDetermination o5Rupture Location% and D(namic E55ect% A%%ociated Bith the )o%tu$ated Rupture o5 )ipin'J Re,

4J March 4..G

/9/, U,S, Nuc$ear Re'u$ator( Commi%%ion? KRe$aation in Ar3itrar( Intermediate )ipe Rupture

Reuirement% :2eneric Letter G800; ME* !80 J Re,4 Hune 09J 09G,

/0./, Re'u$ator( 2uide 0,60 KDampin' 1a$ue% 5or Sei%mic De%i'n o5 Nuc$ear )oBer )$ant% Re,0J

March 4..G



67/69





M-&)*..0.#

R$'.Re,

..

C). *,#.c$a%%

4

Pa-,a)a'e

60 M-&)*..0.# :Ripri%tinato;:Ripri%tinato;49#00..44#.#9,doc


68/69





M-&)*..0.#

R$'.Re,

..

C). *,#.c$a%%

4

Pa-,a)a'e

6=

/4/, )NM!#!4!4G/.! KKI%ometric draBin'% D)S !,0#,.0

/46/, )NM!#!9466 KRoom A4.4/08CC/US)1

/4G/, M-&)*.... KConceptua$ Methodo$o'ica$ Report 5or &E)*

/4/, M-&)*...0!K)ipin' Stre%% Ana$(%i% Report 5or )o%tu$ated *rea+ Location% )+ Line 4#

Inc$udin' TE and &S *rea+ Location%

/49/, KAn Ana$(tica$ Ea$uation o5 Simp$i5ied Method% 5or the A%%e%%ment o5 )ipe hip

Characteri%tic%J M, I'$iJ ), 7ana3oni An%a$do Nuc$eare



69/69





M-&)*..0.#

R$'.Re,

..

C). *,#.c$a%%

4

Pa-,a)a'e

6?

ACRON@MS

AS A"e#ic%n !cle%# Societ

ASE A"e#ic%n Societ of ech%nic%l Enginee#s

ES E"e#genc o#e ooling Sste"

FEA Finite ele"ent %n%lsis

)E )igh Ene#g

P>R Pipe >hip Rest#%int

SRP St%n%# Re$ie( Pl%n

SS St#!ct!#e Sste" %n/o# o"ponent

SSE S%fe Sh!to(n E%#th&!%,e

P+ Pipe +#e%, oc%tion

P; P%c,%ge ines

RS Re%cto# ool%nt e%,%ge ollection Sste"

Enel-Anselmo Nucleare

Documents

Transcript of Enel-Anselmo Nucleare